Ruling on saying in a mudarabah (profit-sharing partnership): “You will have the same as what was stipulated for so-and-so,” when both know it or when they do not know it
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question : If he says, “You will have the same as what was stipulated for so-and-so,” and both of them know it, it is valid. If they do not know it, or if one of them does not know it, it is not valid, and it is not permissible
Answer : that it is valid if so-and-so is someone known for trade and dealing in such matters. Because their specifying the matter by this man, who is known to be experienced, is better than their estimating it themselves, because he might say to you, “Half of the profit,” when he does not deserve it, or “a quarter of it,” when he does not deserve it. So the correct view is to say: If this man, whose work was used to specify the condition, is one of the people of expertise and knowledge, then there is no harm.
Answer : that it is valid if so-and-so is someone known for trade and dealing in such matters. Because their specifying the matter by this man, who is known to be experienced, is better than their estimating it themselves, because he might say to you, “Half of the profit,” when he does not deserve it, or “a quarter of it,” when he does not deserve it. So the correct view is to say: If this man, whose work was used to specify the condition, is one of the people of expertise and knowledge, then there is no harm.
Source
قناة «فضيلة الشيخ محمد بن صالح العثيمين»، [4909] حكم إن قال في شركة المضاربة: لك مثل ما شرط لفلان وهما يعلمانه أو يجهلانه - تعليقات على الكافي
youtube.com
youtube.com
