If one circumambulates on the Shadhrwan, is his tawaf valid?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question : Likewise, the specialists say that in the entire House there is a place called something called the Shadhrwan. This Shadhrwan is what you see at the Ka'bah, may Allah honor it; there is nothing at its bottom like a threshold? It has a threshold at its bottom, up to here. The hadith says do not go far from it. In any case, in its origin, in the base of the wall, it is a ring-shaped thing in the wall like the corner, called by the scholars of knowledge the Shadhrwan. If we suppose that a person circumambulated on it, circumambulated on it with the person, he turned back to him and started walking on it, and this may happen, is his tawaf valid or not valid? What is it?
Answer : Yes, most of the scholars of knowledge say that his tawaf is not valid because it is necessary that he circumambulate the entire House. So if he circumambulated on the Shadhrwan, on this threshold, his tawaf is not valid because the threshold is part of it, the threshold of the House, from the House. Yes, the majority said, and Shaykh al-Islam Ibn Taymiyyah said there is no harm in circumambulating on the Shadhrwan, and that if he circumambulated on the Shadhrwan, his tawaf is valid. His view is that the Shadhrwan is not from the House, but rather it was made a support for it, meaning it is called from it, an aid to the House and not part of it. And each has a position. The majority say our position is that this is an accessory to the House, and the accessory has the ruling of the guaranteed. And his position is that this is not from the House but rather it was made a support for it. And the precaution is not to circumambulate on it, whatever the case may be, because the reality is that his position in matters is good, because the accessory has the ruling of the restricted, just as we said now, what is added to the Sacred Mosque, does it have the ruling of the Sacred Mosque? It has the ruling because it is an accessory to it. So we also say this has the ruling of the House because it is an accessory to it. So the precaution is not to do it, even though the martyrs now in the present time, may Allah reward them with good, the caliphs did not make it valid to be added to it, because it is moved, moved, adjusted, no one can except if one comes to rely on another and...? He walks, okay, yes? Yes, this is it.
Answer : Yes, most of the scholars of knowledge say that his tawaf is not valid because it is necessary that he circumambulate the entire House. So if he circumambulated on the Shadhrwan, on this threshold, his tawaf is not valid because the threshold is part of it, the threshold of the House, from the House. Yes, the majority said, and Shaykh al-Islam Ibn Taymiyyah said there is no harm in circumambulating on the Shadhrwan, and that if he circumambulated on the Shadhrwan, his tawaf is valid. His view is that the Shadhrwan is not from the House, but rather it was made a support for it, meaning it is called from it, an aid to the House and not part of it. And each has a position. The majority say our position is that this is an accessory to the House, and the accessory has the ruling of the guaranteed. And his position is that this is not from the House but rather it was made a support for it. And the precaution is not to circumambulate on it, whatever the case may be, because the reality is that his position in matters is good, because the accessory has the ruling of the restricted, just as we said now, what is added to the Sacred Mosque, does it have the ruling of the Sacred Mosque? It has the ruling because it is an accessory to it. So we also say this has the ruling of the House because it is an accessory to it. So the precaution is not to do it, even though the martyrs now in the present time, may Allah reward them with good, the caliphs did not make it valid to be added to it, because it is moved, moved, adjusted, no one can except if one comes to rely on another and...? He walks, okay, yes? Yes, this is it.
Source
قناة «فضيلة الشيخ محمد بن صالح العثيمين»، 542- لو طاف على الشاذروان، هل يصح طوافه؟ II فوائد من الدروس الفقهية من المحاضرات الجامعية
youtube.com
youtube.com
