One who dies with a debt: Is it paid from zakah?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question : Now, what is your opinion if a person is dead? A person who incurred a debt for himself and died. O people of Thaqif, he died with a debt, and he had a debt.
Answer : Is it permissible for us to pay his debt from the zakah? He is dead, dead, dead, dead, and he left no wealth. Otherwise, if he left wealth, it is paid from his wealth. But we discussed, I think, paying the blood money (diyah) for the deceased, and we understood it to be agreed upon that it is permissible. And in this issue, the scholars have analogized it, and some of them reported it as a consensus that it is not permissible to pay a debt for the deceased from zakah. That is, in this issue, the majority of scholars, indeed their analogy, and indeed Ibn 'Abd al-Barr and Abu 'Ubayd reported it as a consensus that a debt on a deceased person is not paid from it. Some scholars, and they are very few, hold that it is permissible to pay from it, as an indication of ownership if the estate does not suffice. He said: If Allah the Exalted mentioned "and those in debt" in conjunction with "and those in the path," then the eight shares are not paid to those in debt, and there is no counting by ownership, because the one in debt becomes the one seeking, not the one in distress. Is it permissible? No. And there is no difference in that case between the living and the dead, because the one given does not acquire ownership, and there is no difference between the dead and the living. But the correct view is the opinion of the majority, that a debt on a deceased person is not paid from it. And the evidence for this is that the Messenger (peace and blessings be upon him) used to be brought a deceased person with a debt, and he would ask: Does he have? So he did not pray over him. When Allah opened up conquests for him and wealth became abundant with him, he used to say: "Whoever leaves a debt, it is upon his heirs." In the beginning, did he have zakah or did he not have zakah? He had zakah, and yet he did not pay a debt for a deceased person from it. If paying a debt for the deceased from zakah had been permissible, the Messenger (peace and blessings be upon him) would have paid the debt for them so that it could be hoped that he would pray over them, as he did when Allah opened up conquests for them afterwards. So the correct view is that paying a debt for the deceased from zakah is not permissible. And perhaps we can also say: Which need is more pressing, the need of the deceased or the need of the living? The living. Because the living is afflicted by the debt upon him, and the deceased has gone before Allah. If he had taken it intending to repay it, then Allah will repay it for him, as established in the hadith from the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) that he said: Mishkat al-Masabih 2910. And if he did not intend to repay it, Allah will not repay it for him, and it is not permissible for the debt to remain in his liability. But if we pay the debt for the living, we remove the disgrace from him, because if a person is being pursued for a debt, his face is disgraced. It should be beautiful, his face should be beautiful. Therefore, it is said: "Debt is the humiliation of the free man." Debt is the humiliation of the free man. And this is correct. Then, if it is a vow, it becomes a servitude to the Creator.
Answer : Is it permissible for us to pay his debt from the zakah? He is dead, dead, dead, dead, and he left no wealth. Otherwise, if he left wealth, it is paid from his wealth. But we discussed, I think, paying the blood money (diyah) for the deceased, and we understood it to be agreed upon that it is permissible. And in this issue, the scholars have analogized it, and some of them reported it as a consensus that it is not permissible to pay a debt for the deceased from zakah. That is, in this issue, the majority of scholars, indeed their analogy, and indeed Ibn 'Abd al-Barr and Abu 'Ubayd reported it as a consensus that a debt on a deceased person is not paid from it. Some scholars, and they are very few, hold that it is permissible to pay from it, as an indication of ownership if the estate does not suffice. He said: If Allah the Exalted mentioned "and those in debt" in conjunction with "and those in the path," then the eight shares are not paid to those in debt, and there is no counting by ownership, because the one in debt becomes the one seeking, not the one in distress. Is it permissible? No. And there is no difference in that case between the living and the dead, because the one given does not acquire ownership, and there is no difference between the dead and the living. But the correct view is the opinion of the majority, that a debt on a deceased person is not paid from it. And the evidence for this is that the Messenger (peace and blessings be upon him) used to be brought a deceased person with a debt, and he would ask: Does he have
Who has fulfilled it? If they say yes, he steps forward and prays over him. If they say no, he says: Pray over him.
من وفاء؟ فإن قالوا نعم تقدم وصلى عليه، وإن قالوا لا قال صلوا علىIf anyone accepts other people’s belongings meaning to pay back, God will pay back for him
قال من أخذ أموال الناس يريد أداءها أدى الله عنه
Source
قناة «فضيلة الشيخ محمد بن صالح العثيمين»، 451- من مات وعليه دَين: هل يُقضى من الزكاة؟ II فوائد من الدروس الفقهية من المحاضرات الجامعية
youtube.com
youtube.com
