What is the ruling on marriage by shighar if the mahr is specified?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question : But if this situation occurs, what do we do? This situation has occurred. He stipulated that he would marry his daughter to him, and he married his daughter to him, and children were born from the women, yes?
Answer : So what do we do? We say: As for the view that if the mahr is specified and both women are satisfied and each party is a suitable match, then the marriage is valid and there is nothing wrong with it. As for the view that it is forbidden absolutely, then in this case the marriage is defective, not invalid, because an invalid marriage is one on which the scholars have agreed regarding its invalidity or its defectiveness, and the scholars have differed on this. If it is defective, then the case must be brought before the judge, the religious authority. If he rules that the contract is valid, it is carried out; and if he rules that it is defective, it is defective, because one of the established principles among the people of knowledge is that the judge's ruling resolves the disagreement. So the case is brought to the court, and whatever the judge rules is followed. Yes, as I told you, the stronger view based on the meaning of the hadith is that if the mahr is specified and both parties are satisfied and each spouse is a suitable match, it is not a problem. However, we see the need to close the door in these crises.
Answer : So what do we do? We say: As for the view that if the mahr is specified and both women are satisfied and each party is a suitable match, then the marriage is valid and there is nothing wrong with it. As for the view that it is forbidden absolutely, then in this case the marriage is defective, not invalid, because an invalid marriage is one on which the scholars have agreed regarding its invalidity or its defectiveness, and the scholars have differed on this. If it is defective, then the case must be brought before the judge, the religious authority. If he rules that the contract is valid, it is carried out; and if he rules that it is defective, it is defective, because one of the established principles among the people of knowledge is that the judge's ruling resolves the disagreement. So the case is brought to the court, and whatever the judge rules is followed. Yes, as I told you, the stronger view based on the meaning of the hadith is that if the mahr is specified and both parties are satisfied and each spouse is a suitable match, it is not a problem. However, we see the need to close the door in these crises.
Source
قناة «فضيلة الشيخ محمد بن صالح العثيمين»، 1947 - 4600 ما حكم نكاح الشغار إذا سمي المهر؟ ابن عثيمين
youtube.com
youtube.com
