What is a vow of righteousness?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question : And what does it mean that it is a vow of righteousness?
Answer : Yes. I mean, what is it? It comes from righteousness (birr) and from disavowal (bara'). A vow of righteousness means one intended by it obedience, because a vow may be a vow of righteousness or a vow of prevention. For example, if someone says, "By Allah, I have a vow upon me for Allah: if I speak to so-and-so, I will certainly give charity with his money," is this a vow of righteousness or not? No, it is not a vow of righteousness; he did not intend righteousness, he intended prevention. He intended prevention. In this vow, he is not required to give charity with his money. We say: if you wish, give charity, and if you wish, expiate it with the expiation of an oath. For example, if he says, "If I wear this garment, I have a vow upon me for Allah to give charity with all my clothes," is this a vow of righteousness or not? No, his intention is also prevention. We say now: if you wear the garment, if you wish, give charity with all the clothes, and if you wish, expiate it with the expiation of an oath. If he says, "If Allah gives me money, I have a vow upon me for Allah to give charity with a quarter of it," is this a vow of righteousness? Is he required to give charity? Yes. So, a vow of righteousness is one intended for righteousness and obedience, and other than a vow of righteousness is one not intended for that.
Answer : Yes. I mean, what is it? It comes from righteousness (birr) and from disavowal (bara'). A vow of righteousness means one intended by it obedience, because a vow may be a vow of righteousness or a vow of prevention. For example, if someone says, "By Allah, I have a vow upon me for Allah: if I speak to so-and-so, I will certainly give charity with his money," is this a vow of righteousness or not? No, it is not a vow of righteousness; he did not intend righteousness, he intended prevention. He intended prevention. In this vow, he is not required to give charity with his money. We say: if you wish, give charity, and if you wish, expiate it with the expiation of an oath. For example, if he says, "If I wear this garment, I have a vow upon me for Allah to give charity with all my clothes," is this a vow of righteousness or not? No, his intention is also prevention. We say now: if you wear the garment, if you wish, give charity with all the clothes, and if you wish, expiate it with the expiation of an oath. If he says, "If Allah gives me money, I have a vow upon me for Allah to give charity with a quarter of it," is this a vow of righteousness? Is he required to give charity? Yes. So, a vow of righteousness is one intended for righteousness and obedience, and other than a vow of righteousness is one not intended for that.
Source
قناة «فضيلة الشيخ محمد بن صالح العثيمين»، 520 - ما هو نذر التبرر؟ قواعد ابن رجب - ابن عثيمين
youtube.com
youtube.com
