Is it correct to say that selling an item for ten cash or twenty on credit involves riba (usury or interest)?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner : Shaykh, may Allah reward you. They say, in this very hadith, that the one who says this—selling for ten cash or twenty on credit—they say he sold the item for ten, and its price does not exceed ten dirhams. He sold these ten dirhams for twenty, even though it is four.
The Shaykh : For ten, may Allah bless you. You did not take it for ten, then you came back and said, "Let's make it deferred for twenty." If you had taken it for ten and the option to cancel was cut off, then you went back and said, "By Allah, O son of the noble one, I took it from you for ten, thinking I would get ten as a gift, but I did not get it, so leave it at twenty for a year." This is forbidden. Why?
Because the price settled on you. How much is the machine? Ten. How do you make it twenty in exchange for the delay? But from the start, I did not take it for ten. I was given the choice between two prices and I took the ten. Be patient, is that clear? Good. So I say that the issues of disagreement are everywhere, not just in transactions. A person must seek precision in them and not take things for granted. How many issues have passed us now? Many issues. Selling as people sell, selling by number, selling as so-and-so sells. The well-known, relied-upon position in al-Hadi says it is not valid. But if you examine it, you will find that it is more likely to be valid than the price cut off by the seller. Is that clear? Good, may Allah bless you.
The Shaykh : For ten, may Allah bless you. You did not take it for ten, then you came back and said, "Let's make it deferred for twenty." If you had taken it for ten and the option to cancel was cut off, then you went back and said, "By Allah, O son of the noble one, I took it from you for ten, thinking I would get ten as a gift, but I did not get it, so leave it at twenty for a year." This is forbidden. Why?
Because the price settled on you. How much is the machine? Ten. How do you make it twenty in exchange for the delay? But from the start, I did not take it for ten. I was given the choice between two prices and I took the ten. Be patient, is that clear? Good. So I say that the issues of disagreement are everywhere, not just in transactions. A person must seek precision in them and not take things for granted. How many issues have passed us now? Many issues. Selling as people sell, selling by number, selling as so-and-so sells. The well-known, relied-upon position in al-Hadi says it is not valid. But if you examine it, you will find that it is more likely to be valid than the price cut off by the seller. Is that clear? Good, may Allah bless you.
Source
قناة «فضيلة الشيخ محمد بن صالح العثيمين»، [3934] هل يصح القول بأن بيع السلعة بعشرة نقدًا أو عشرين نسيئة فيه ربا؟ - تعليقات على الكافي
youtube.com
youtube.com
