The ruling on performing 'Umrah on behalf of two people in a single 'Umrah!!!
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question : The question has become frequent, Honorable Shaykh, regarding whether it is permissible to combine 'Umrah for two deceased parents in a single 'Umrah? This is the answer to that.
Answer : Based on this, we say: No, it is not permissible for a single act of worship to be performed on behalf of two or more people. In fact, if one recites the talbiyah for a single act of worship on behalf of two people, the reward belongs to him alone.
For example, if someone says, "Labbaik (I respond to you) for an 'Umrah on behalf of my mother and my father," we say this is not permissible, and the 'Umrah belongs to the one who recited the talbiyah, not to his mother or his father. Here we point out what some people do, which is repeating 'Umrah every day, or every other day, in a single journey. This is a bid'ah (religious innovation); it was not the way of the Companions to repeat 'Umrah in a single journey. Rather, each journey has only one 'Umrah. What many people do today has no basis. And if it has no basis in the Shari'ah of Allah, it becomes a bid'ah. In fact, Shaykh al-Islam (may Allah have mercy on him) mentioned that performing 'Umrah frequently and repeating it is disliked (makruh) by the consensus of the Salaf. How much more so if this man wants to repeat it ten times in ten days? The first day for himself, the second for whom? For his mother, the third and fourth for his grandmother, the fifth for his grandfather, the sixth for his maternal grandfather and maternal grandmother, then it is the turn of the brother, sister, maternal uncle, maternal aunt, paternal uncle, and paternal aunt, and so on. Who says that this is prescribed (mashru') and part of the religion of Allah? Some of the scholars of the Salaf even said, "I do not know about these people who go out to al-Tan'im and perform 'Umrah; I do not know whether they are committing a sin or being rewarded?"
So the matter is wrong; the matter is wrong and has no basis. And I think I have told you more than once about the man we saw performing sa'y with half of his head completely shaved. Half of his head was white like a cloud, and the other half was black like the dark night. We asked him about it, why? And we said this is the disliked practice of qaza' (shaving the head in patches). He said, "This is for yesterday's 'Umrah, and the rest is for today's 'Umrah." I do not know if this man wanted to take four or five 'Umrahs, dividing the head by shares, with each 'Umrah having a part of the head. If he wanted to take four 'Umrahs, he would shave a quarter; for five 'Umrahs, he would take a fifth, and so on. And as becomes clear upon reflection, all of this is due to the strength of religious emotion in the hearts of these people; they love to increase in good. But the love of increasing in good must be tied to the Shari'ah. Did this come in the Shari'ah? If it is said yes, we say, "Go ahead, increase." If it is said no, we say, "Stop, do not do what the Shari'ah did not bring." Please.
Answer : Based on this, we say: No, it is not permissible for a single act of worship to be performed on behalf of two or more people. In fact, if one recites the talbiyah for a single act of worship on behalf of two people, the reward belongs to him alone.
For example, if someone says, "Labbaik (I respond to you) for an 'Umrah on behalf of my mother and my father," we say this is not permissible, and the 'Umrah belongs to the one who recited the talbiyah, not to his mother or his father. Here we point out what some people do, which is repeating 'Umrah every day, or every other day, in a single journey. This is a bid'ah (religious innovation); it was not the way of the Companions to repeat 'Umrah in a single journey. Rather, each journey has only one 'Umrah. What many people do today has no basis. And if it has no basis in the Shari'ah of Allah, it becomes a bid'ah. In fact, Shaykh al-Islam (may Allah have mercy on him) mentioned that performing 'Umrah frequently and repeating it is disliked (makruh) by the consensus of the Salaf. How much more so if this man wants to repeat it ten times in ten days? The first day for himself, the second for whom? For his mother, the third and fourth for his grandmother, the fifth for his grandfather, the sixth for his maternal grandfather and maternal grandmother, then it is the turn of the brother, sister, maternal uncle, maternal aunt, paternal uncle, and paternal aunt, and so on. Who says that this is prescribed (mashru') and part of the religion of Allah? Some of the scholars of the Salaf even said, "I do not know about these people who go out to al-Tan'im and perform 'Umrah; I do not know whether they are committing a sin or being rewarded?"
So the matter is wrong; the matter is wrong and has no basis. And I think I have told you more than once about the man we saw performing sa'y with half of his head completely shaved. Half of his head was white like a cloud, and the other half was black like the dark night. We asked him about it, why? And we said this is the disliked practice of qaza' (shaving the head in patches). He said, "This is for yesterday's 'Umrah, and the rest is for today's 'Umrah." I do not know if this man wanted to take four or five 'Umrahs, dividing the head by shares, with each 'Umrah having a part of the head. If he wanted to take four 'Umrahs, he would shave a quarter; for five 'Umrahs, he would take a fifth, and so on. And as becomes clear upon reflection, all of this is due to the strength of religious emotion in the hearts of these people; they love to increase in good. But the love of increasing in good must be tied to the Shari'ah. Did this come in the Shari'ah? If it is said yes, we say, "Go ahead, increase." If it is said no, we say, "Stop, do not do what the Shari'ah did not bring." Please.
Source
قناة «فضيلة الشيخ محمد بن صالح العثيمين»، لقاء[24 من 70] حكم من يعتمر عن شخصين بعمرة واحدة!!! الشيخ ابن عثيمين - مشروع كبار العلماء
youtube.com
youtube.com
