Text copied Link copied

Al-Fatawa – home

﴿ فَاسْأَلُوا أَهْلَ الذِّكْرِ إِن كُنتُمْ لَا تَعْلَمُونَ ﴾

Scholar
Search mode

Is the person of legal capacity free to choose between the points of disagreement among scholars?

Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question : The questioner asks: Is the person of legal capacity free to choose between the points of disagreement among scholars, to select whichever opinion he wishes? Is every opinion claimed with evidence, such that there is no blame on him for that, or is there? We ask for clarification.

Answer : This question is very important, especially in this time when people have become acquainted with the opinions of scholars, and they have come to hear or read about the disagreement among the people of knowledge. We say first that it is obligatory for the scholars who differ on these issues not to make this disagreement a cause of enmity, hatred, discord, and division, because that is not the way of the Muslims. Allah, Blessed and Exalted is He, said:
And do not be like the ones who became divided and differed afterوَلَا تَكُونُوا كَالَّذِينَ تَفَرَّقُوا وَاخْتَلَفُوا مِن بَعْدِ مَا
[Ali 'Imran 3:105]
came
the clear proofs had come to them. And those will have a great punishment.جَاءَهُمُ الْبَيِّنَاتُ وَأُولَٰئِكَ لَهُمْ عَذَابٌ عَظِيمٌ
[Ali 'Imran 3:105]
, and Allah the Exalted said to His Prophet:
Indeed, those who have divided their religion and become sects - you, [O Muhammad], are not [associated] with them in anything. Their affair is only [left] to Allah; then He will inform them about what they used to do.إِنَّ الَّذِينَ فَرَّقُوا دِينَهُمْ وَكَانُوا شِيَعًا لَّسْتَ مِنْهُمْ فِي شَيْءٍ إِنَّمَا أَمْرُهُمْ إِلَى اللَّهِ ثُمَّ يُنَبِّئُهُم بِمَا كَانُوا يَفْعَلُونَ
[Al-An'am 6:159]
.
And what we see and hear, unfortunately, is that these people who differ take their disagreement as a path to conflict, discord, and the division of the Ummah, saying, "You are with me and not with so-and-so?" and the like of the words we hear. This is an error. It is obligatory that if a person knows that the other’s intention is good, and that he seeks the truth, and that he has not contradicted an explicit text, but rather has differed on a matter where there is room for ijtihad (independent legal reasoning), then it is permissible. It is not befitting to be hostile toward him for this, nor to take his disagreement as a means to divide the Muslims. For this reason, the Companions (may Allah be pleased with them) differed on many issues, yet they were on the heart of one man, with no conflict or disagreement among them. This is regarding those who differ. As for those who hear these differing opinions, it is undoubtedly better for a man to follow the one he sees as closer to the truth, the one he sees as closer to the truth. Because the man who has heard the disagreement is in the position of a patient for whom two or more doctors have prescribed treatment for his illness; undoubtedly, he will take the opinion of the doctor he sees as closer, either in his knowledge or in this manner. Likewise, issues of Islamic jurisprudence are medicine for the hearts. So a person should, when he hears the disagreement of the scholars, take the one he sees as closer to the truth in his statement, either because of the breadth of his knowledge, or because of his religion and trustworthiness. And I say that it is befitting, and I do not say that it is obligatory, because some of the scholars hold that it is obligatory to take the opinion of the one one sees as closer to the truth. But I do not see that it is obligatory. This is because if a dispute occurs between two scholars, and one is closer to the truth in a statement, it does not necessitate that he is closer to the truth in every issue. For we find that great scholars err on one of the issues, and one who is below them in knowledge is more correct than them. Therefore, we do not see that it is obligatory for a person to take the statement of the one who is more knowledgeable in every issue. And because if we made that obligatory, we would make obligatory the following of other than the Messenger (peace and blessings be upon him), and taqlid (following a scholar without knowing his evidence) of other than the Messenger (peace and blessings be upon him). And this is the matter that brought the calamity upon the Islamic Ummah in the division into the schools of jurisprudence that arose after the time of the Messenger (peace and blessings be upon him). As for if the two scholars are unknown to this questioner or to this listener, and he does not know which of them is closer to the truth in his knowledge or trustworthiness, the scholars have also differed on whether it is obligatory for him to take the stricter opinion because it is safer, or to take the easier opinion because it is in accordance with the Shari'ah. For the Shari'ah is all, as the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) said, that
The religion is easy.الدين يسر.
And the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) was never given a choice between two things except that he chose the easier of them. So if you are ignorant of the state of the two differing scholars, some of the scholars hold that you take the stricter one, because it is safer, and some hold that you take the easier one, because it is more in accordance with the spirit of Islam. And knowledge is with Allah.
Source قناة «فضيلة الشيخ محمد بن صالح العثيمين»، 1 - 12 - دروس وفتاوى المسجد الحرام للعام 1406 هـ - الدرس الأول - الشيخ محمد بن صالح العثيمين
youtube.com (19:23)
Flag this fatwa