If a person carries another person in ihram during tawaf, is it required that each of them intends the tawaf?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner : His father or mother or whoever is responsible for him carries him. And if he is carried, is it permissible for the carrier to also intend the tawaf?
The Shaykh : It is permissible for the carrier to intend the tawaf, and the one being carried also intends the tawaf? Some scholars said it is permissible for the carrier to intend the tawaf and for the one being carried to intend the tawaf, because the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) said that every person gets what he intended. This carrier, if it is said that the carrier does not walk, the carrier has an interest; the carrier wants to perform tawaf in any case. Is it not permissible for him to intend or not to intend? It is permissible to perform tawaf without intending it, and it is permissible to perform tawaf with the intention. And the Messenger (peace and blessings be upon him) said:Sahih al-Bukhari 1 The carrier intended and the one being carried intended, so every person gets what he intended. On this basis, if it is possible that the one being carried does not understand, meaning his father or mother carried him, is that similar?
And is it obligatory? We say it is not obligatory, because this questioner clarified that the prayer is for himself and for the child. This means one action cannot be intended by two people; an action in which two intentions occur is not possible. Therefore, the opinion we hold is that if the one being carried does not have an intention, and he told the carrier that the correct thing is [to do so], then there is no harm in performing tawaf and intending it for himself, and the carrier also performs tawaf and intends it for himself. However, if the one being carried does not have an intention, it is not valid for the carrier to intend it for himself, because he is performing tawaf with the intention of the one being carried, since the one being carried has no intention now. And here is an issue that women must agree on: the one being carried must keep the House on his left. If you have a child and you pray with him on your shoulder, he sits here and sits here, and his back is toward the House or his face is toward the House. Are they happy or not?
If you carry him and, for example, leave his face toward the House, and leave him on the left, what happens? His face is toward the House. If you leave him on the right, his face is toward the House. This is not permissible. It must be on his left. How should he carry him?
Yes, he carries him on his neck, he carries him on his head. Yes? Likewise, if he does not carry him on his head, meaning he carries him on [his shoulder], or he does what some African women do, leaving it to confusion, and ties him to her, on a pole. This is a calculation, although it is a dangerous habit. This is a dangerous habit, and I am surprised at my copy [transcription] how it was not used.
The Shaykh : It is permissible for the carrier to intend the tawaf, and the one being carried also intends the tawaf? Some scholars said it is permissible for the carrier to intend the tawaf and for the one being carried to intend the tawaf, because the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) said that every person gets what he intended. This carrier, if it is said that the carrier does not walk, the carrier has an interest; the carrier wants to perform tawaf in any case. Is it not permissible for him to intend or not to intend? It is permissible to perform tawaf without intending it, and it is permissible to perform tawaf with the intention. And the Messenger (peace and blessings be upon him) said:
and every person will get the reward according to what he has intended
وإنما لكل امرئ ما نوىAnd is it obligatory? We say it is not obligatory, because this questioner clarified that the prayer is for himself and for the child. This means one action cannot be intended by two people; an action in which two intentions occur is not possible. Therefore, the opinion we hold is that if the one being carried does not have an intention, and he told the carrier that the correct thing is [to do so], then there is no harm in performing tawaf and intending it for himself, and the carrier also performs tawaf and intends it for himself. However, if the one being carried does not have an intention, it is not valid for the carrier to intend it for himself, because he is performing tawaf with the intention of the one being carried, since the one being carried has no intention now. And here is an issue that women must agree on: the one being carried must keep the House on his left. If you have a child and you pray with him on your shoulder, he sits here and sits here, and his back is toward the House or his face is toward the House. Are they happy or not?
If you carry him and, for example, leave his face toward the House, and leave him on the left, what happens? His face is toward the House. If you leave him on the right, his face is toward the House. This is not permissible. It must be on his left. How should he carry him?
Yes, he carries him on his neck, he carries him on his head. Yes? Likewise, if he does not carry him on his head, meaning he carries him on [his shoulder], or he does what some African women do, leaving it to confusion, and ties him to her, on a pole. This is a calculation, although it is a dangerous habit. This is a dangerous habit, and I am surprised at my copy [transcription] how it was not used.
Source
قناة «فضيلة الشيخ محمد بن صالح العثيمين»، 579- إذا طاف حاملًا شخصًا آخر محرمًا، فهل يشترط أن ينوي كلٌّ منهما الطواف؟ II ابن عثيمين
youtube.com
youtube.com
