Is it recommended for the one in i'tikaf (spiritual retreat in the mosque) to remain in his place of retreat on the night of the festival and not go out except to the place of the festival prayer?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question : Is it recommended that he remain in his place of retreat on the night of the festival and not go out except to the place of the festival prayer? And the second issue is: does he go out to the festival in a state of adornment and wearing perfume, or in his clothes of i'tikaf?
Answer : As for the first issue, there is no evidence for it, except for these reports (athar) that he mentioned. And reports from the successors (Tabi'un) are not a proof. Based on that, if a person were to ask: "Is it better for me to remain in the mosque on the night of the festival while in i'tikaf, or should I go to my family on that night so that I may find comfort in them and they in me?" We would say the second is better, because there is no evidence for the recommendation of remaining on the night of the festival.
Answer : As for the first issue, there is no evidence for it, except for these reports (athar) that he mentioned. And reports from the successors (Tabi'un) are not a proof. Based on that, if a person were to ask: "Is it better for me to remain in the mosque on the night of the festival while in i'tikaf, or should I go to my family on that night so that I may find comfort in them and they in me?" We would say the second is better, because there is no evidence for the recommendation of remaining on the night of the festival.
Source
قناة «فضيلة الشيخ محمد بن صالح العثيمين»، 2380 - هل يستحب للمعتكف أن يبقى ليلة العيد في معتكفه ولا يخرج إلا إلى مصلى العيد؟ ابن عثيمين
youtube.com
youtube.com
