Is it permissible for a student of knowledge to say, "This hadith is not found in what I know"?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question : May Allah bless you. If a beginner student of knowledge is asked about a matter, for example, and he says, "Such and such is what I know," or "This hadith does not appear in what I know,"
Answer : Yes. If he is a beginner student of knowledge, he should not say this. Only a man who has searched and investigated and found nothing should say this. As for a person who knows only the hadiths of *Umdat al-Ahkam* (the core of rulings), and then is asked about many hadiths that are not in *Umdat al-Ahkam* and says, "I do not know," he has no knowledge of this at all. Then, when a person hears the phrase "in what I know" and does not know the person himself, he might think, "This is one of the four Imams." Yes, this is a problem; this is misleading.
Answer : Yes. If he is a beginner student of knowledge, he should not say this. Only a man who has searched and investigated and found nothing should say this. As for a person who knows only the hadiths of *Umdat al-Ahkam* (the core of rulings), and then is asked about many hadiths that are not in *Umdat al-Ahkam* and says, "I do not know," he has no knowledge of this at all. Then, when a person hears the phrase "in what I know" and does not know the person himself, he might think, "This is one of the four Imams." Yes, this is a problem; this is misleading.
Source
قناة «فضيلة الشيخ محمد بن صالح العثيمين»، 238 - 4600 هل يصح لطالب العلم أن يقول هذا الحديث لم يرد في ما أعلم؟ ابن عثيمين
youtube.com
youtube.com
