Partnership between two parties, one owning the capital and the other providing the labor
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner : Partnership between two parties, one owning the capital and the other providing the labor.
The Shaykh : If the partnership is in what grows from the work, such as profit, it is permissible, like a mudarabah. It is similar to the case of one who gives his animal or slave to someone to work on it for a share of its earnings; this is permissible according to the more correct view. For example, if I give this man an animal and say, “Take it, work on it, load it, and you will have half of what you earn,” is that permissible or not? It is permissible, because this is exactly like a mudarabah. In a mudarabah, I give him money to trade with, and here I give him an asset to work with, and he has a share of its earnings, so it is permissible according to the more correct view. The same applies if it is a car; I give him this car to work in it, and he has a share of the fare. However, if the partnership is in what arises from the substance of the capital, such as the milk of an animal or its offspring, there are two narrations. An example of this is: “Take these three sheep, breed them, and you will have half of their offspring.” Is that permissible or not? There are two narrations on this, because the specified share for the worker—where is it taken from? There is no god but Allah.
From the milk of the animal. Likewise, if I said, “Take this sheep, work on it, meaning be its shepherd and attend to its needs, and you will have half of the milk,” what is your view? Where is the brother we reached who is buying us a rifle or a pistol? Hmm? Even… Jadd, come on, brother, it is not Wednesday; if Allah wills, he will be present on Thursday, so hurry up with Jadd so he can pay for it so that those far away can get it. The discussion passes by.
No, only air passes through them, okay. The point is, if I said, “Take this sheep,” meaning it is impossible, there are two narrations on this: one permitting it and one prohibiting it. What is the practice of the people now? Permissibility. Do you know about this, brother Isa? Khalid, do you know that this is the practice of the people? Yes. Yes. It appears that the practice of the people is this. The “adawlah” now, they call it “adawlah,” Ghanim, is it of this type? The personal “adawlah” is that one promises to accept it and return it. Is there nothing from it? There is nothing. Okay, he has a term for all the milk. Yes, not the spirit.
The same thing. The author says with a share of its offspring or milk, and the explicit case is that he takes all the milk, so it is even more prohibited. The important point is that the correct view is permissibility. Hmm? Hmm? Two forms. Yes. Who is the one who is named? Listen, Ghanim, he asked for the cow. No, no, may Allah have mercy on your parents. It is not, it is not expensive. Yes.
The questioner : What is this thing? I have no problem; she is going to Yemen to bring it. Answer. Yes.
The Shaykh : There is disagreement regarding the rule; the root of the rule involves disagreement.
The Shaykh : If the partnership is in what grows from the work, such as profit, it is permissible, like a mudarabah. It is similar to the case of one who gives his animal or slave to someone to work on it for a share of its earnings; this is permissible according to the more correct view. For example, if I give this man an animal and say, “Take it, work on it, load it, and you will have half of what you earn,” is that permissible or not? It is permissible, because this is exactly like a mudarabah. In a mudarabah, I give him money to trade with, and here I give him an asset to work with, and he has a share of its earnings, so it is permissible according to the more correct view. The same applies if it is a car; I give him this car to work in it, and he has a share of the fare. However, if the partnership is in what arises from the substance of the capital, such as the milk of an animal or its offspring, there are two narrations. An example of this is: “Take these three sheep, breed them, and you will have half of their offspring.” Is that permissible or not? There are two narrations on this, because the specified share for the worker—where is it taken from? There is no god but Allah.
From the milk of the animal. Likewise, if I said, “Take this sheep, work on it, meaning be its shepherd and attend to its needs, and you will have half of the milk,” what is your view? Where is the brother we reached who is buying us a rifle or a pistol? Hmm? Even… Jadd, come on, brother, it is not Wednesday; if Allah wills, he will be present on Thursday, so hurry up with Jadd so he can pay for it so that those far away can get it. The discussion passes by.
No, only air passes through them, okay. The point is, if I said, “Take this sheep,” meaning it is impossible, there are two narrations on this: one permitting it and one prohibiting it. What is the practice of the people now? Permissibility. Do you know about this, brother Isa? Khalid, do you know that this is the practice of the people? Yes. Yes. It appears that the practice of the people is this. The “adawlah” now, they call it “adawlah,” Ghanim, is it of this type? The personal “adawlah” is that one promises to accept it and return it. Is there nothing from it? There is nothing. Okay, he has a term for all the milk. Yes, not the spirit.
The same thing. The author says with a share of its offspring or milk, and the explicit case is that he takes all the milk, so it is even more prohibited. The important point is that the correct view is permissibility. Hmm? Hmm? Two forms. Yes. Who is the one who is named? Listen, Ghanim, he asked for the cow. No, no, may Allah have mercy on your parents. It is not, it is not expensive. Yes.
The questioner : What is this thing? I have no problem; she is going to Yemen to bring it. Answer. Yes.
The Shaykh : There is disagreement regarding the rule; the root of the rule involves disagreement.
Source
قناة «فضيلة الشيخ محمد بن صالح العثيمين»، 226 - المشاركة بين اثنين بملك أحدهما وعمل الآخر - قواعد ابن رجب - ابن عثيمين
youtube.com
youtube.com
