If a person performs wudu' with stolen water, is his prayer valid?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner : Wudu' is a condition for the validity of the prayer. So, if a person performs wudu' with stolen water, is his prayer valid or not?
The Shaykh : There are two narrations on this, because the prohibition here relates to a condition of the act of worship, but in a way that is not specific to it. The prohibition against using stolen property is not specific to wudu'; rather, if you used stolen water for your food, drink, or washing your clothes, it would be forbidden, would it not? So, is the prohibition specific to the condition of the act of worship, or is it not specific? It is not specific. For this reason, there are two narrations from Imam Ahmad, and the correct view is that the wudu' is valid and the prayer is valid. This is because the prohibition here is not that the Messenger (peace and blessings be upon him) said, "Do not perform wudu' with stolen water," which would have related to the mention of the condition. Rather, it is a prohibition against using stolen property, i.e., the property of another, because it is the right of another. So, the prohibition here is not of the act of worship itself, but of violating the sanctity of another's property. Therefore, the second narration is that wudu' with stolen water is valid, while the school's position is that it is not valid. Yes.
The presenter : This is like the prayer of Thursday. Allah.
The Shaykh : You are coming now, wait. Yes.
The presenter : I am composed on.
The Shaykh : The most famous of them in the school, meaning.
The presenter : Meaning it is a blessing of the house.
The Shaykh : No, no, the most famous among the early scholars may be contrary to the school's position among the later scholars, because you need to know in which century the author lived. In the eighth century, a scholar came after him. Yes.
The Shaykh : There are two narrations on this, because the prohibition here relates to a condition of the act of worship, but in a way that is not specific to it. The prohibition against using stolen property is not specific to wudu'; rather, if you used stolen water for your food, drink, or washing your clothes, it would be forbidden, would it not? So, is the prohibition specific to the condition of the act of worship, or is it not specific? It is not specific. For this reason, there are two narrations from Imam Ahmad, and the correct view is that the wudu' is valid and the prayer is valid. This is because the prohibition here is not that the Messenger (peace and blessings be upon him) said, "Do not perform wudu' with stolen water," which would have related to the mention of the condition. Rather, it is a prohibition against using stolen property, i.e., the property of another, because it is the right of another. So, the prohibition here is not of the act of worship itself, but of violating the sanctity of another's property. Therefore, the second narration is that wudu' with stolen water is valid, while the school's position is that it is not valid. Yes.
The presenter : This is like the prayer of Thursday. Allah.
The Shaykh : You are coming now, wait. Yes.
The presenter : I am composed on.
The Shaykh : The most famous of them in the school, meaning.
The presenter : Meaning it is a blessing of the house.
The Shaykh : No, no, the most famous among the early scholars may be contrary to the school's position among the later scholars, because you need to know in which century the author lived. In the eighth century, a scholar came after him. Yes.
Source
قناة «فضيلة الشيخ محمد بن صالح العثيمين»، 109 - إذا توضأ الإنسان بماء مغصوب هل تصح صلاته؟ قواعد ابن رجب - ابن عثيمين
youtube.com
youtube.com
