What are the conditions for breastfeeding that establishes prohibition if the wife's mother informs that she breastfed him?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner : This questioner says: Honorable Shaykh! I married a woman, and Allah granted me children from her. After a period, the wife's mother informed me that she had breastfed me for an unknown duration. He says: I am now confused, what should I do?
The Shaykh : Breastfeeding must be known. It must be known to be five breastfeedings or more. If a woman breastfed a child twice, she is not his mother; three times, she is not his mother; four times, she is not his mother; five times, she becomes his mother. It is necessary for the breastfeeding to be five times, each time separated from the other. So if the child was breastfed three or four times, he is not the son of the woman.
And then we say to this informer who informed that she breastfed the man: you must inform how many times you breastfed this man. If she says, "I do not know," we say there is no ruling for this breastfeeding. And we have pointed out in these gatherings that the effect of breastfeeding does not extend to whom? The breastfed child and his descendants, and the wet nurse and her husband. As for the breastfed child and his descendants, it is apparent that the sons of the breastfed child become mahram (forbidden relatives) to the one who breastfed him because she is his grandmother. And as for the wet nurse, the meaning is that if the wet nurse breastfed the child with the breastfeeding that establishes prohibition, she becomes his mother, and her brothers become his maternal uncles, and her fathers become his grandfathers, and so does the father. The one who is the owner of the milk, if a woman breastfed a child from her husband, he becomes the father of this child, and his brothers become the child's paternal uncles, and his sisters become the child's paternal aunts, and his mother becomes the child's grandmother, and so on. Now, is it possible to establish motherhood in breastfeeding without fatherhood? Meaning that the man has a mother from breastfeeding but no father. He has a mother from breastfeeding but no father. Give the example. The example was not given. So she is the mother and he has no father. Okay, the example is: a woman breastfed a child while she was in the marriage bond with her husband. She breastfed the child three times, then her husband divorced her and she married another, and she became pregnant from him and breastfed the child how many times? Two times. Here she is the mother because she breastfed the child five times, and he does not have a father because he was breastfed from the milk of the first three times and from the milk of the second two times. Conversely, for example, is it possible for there to be a child who has a father from breastfeeding but no mother from breastfeeding? He has a father from breastfeeding but no mother. He has no mother from breastfeeding. Three times, five times, unless you satisfied him. If you satisfied him. Yes. Hurry.
You heard the answer. A man has two wives. One of them breastfed this child twice and the other breastfed him three times. Here he has a father from breastfeeding but no mother from breastfeeding. So his mother, because if we say his first mother, it is not correct because she did not breastfeed him except twice, and if we say the second, she is not his mother because she did not breastfeed him except three times. But the milk is the husband's milk, so the husband is his father from breastfeeding and he has no mother from breastfeeding. No, the condition is not just satisfaction, but that they are separated from each other. The first and second case in which it is established? What do you say about this? If the child has a mother from breastfeeding but no father, do the children of the second and first husband become brothers to the one who has a mother from breastfeeding? The children of the two husbands from the woman who breastfed are brothers from the mother, brothers from the mother. And as for the children of the two husbands from other than the one who breastfed, they are not brothers, they are not brothers. Did you understand? Did you understand, people, or not? Okay.
A man has two wives. A woman breastfed a child at her husband's house two times, then she left him and married another, and breastfed this child three times, so the total breastfeedings became five breastfeedings. Thus, the prohibition is established from the side of the mother. The children of the mother who breastfed the child, whether from the first husband or the second husband, are brothers to the breastfed child from the mother. The children of the two husbands from other than the wet nurse are not brothers, because the fatherhood from breastfeeding was not established for the father, and those who branch off from him follow him. Okay, does the husband's father become a grandfather to the breastfed child? No, because if the fatherhood is not established, what branches off from it is not established. Yes, correct.
The second case: a man has two wives. One of them breastfed this child three times and the other child two times. Motherhood was not established, but fatherhood was established. Accordingly, the children of the husband become brothers to this breastfed child, whether the children are from the two wet-nurse wives or from previous wives. Yes. Forbidden, forbidden, yes.
The questioner : May Allah reward you.
The Shaykh : Breastfeeding must be known. It must be known to be five breastfeedings or more. If a woman breastfed a child twice, she is not his mother; three times, she is not his mother; four times, she is not his mother; five times, she becomes his mother. It is necessary for the breastfeeding to be five times, each time separated from the other. So if the child was breastfed three or four times, he is not the son of the woman.
And then we say to this informer who informed that she breastfed the man: you must inform how many times you breastfed this man. If she says, "I do not know," we say there is no ruling for this breastfeeding. And we have pointed out in these gatherings that the effect of breastfeeding does not extend to whom? The breastfed child and his descendants, and the wet nurse and her husband. As for the breastfed child and his descendants, it is apparent that the sons of the breastfed child become mahram (forbidden relatives) to the one who breastfed him because she is his grandmother. And as for the wet nurse, the meaning is that if the wet nurse breastfed the child with the breastfeeding that establishes prohibition, she becomes his mother, and her brothers become his maternal uncles, and her fathers become his grandfathers, and so does the father. The one who is the owner of the milk, if a woman breastfed a child from her husband, he becomes the father of this child, and his brothers become the child's paternal uncles, and his sisters become the child's paternal aunts, and his mother becomes the child's grandmother, and so on. Now, is it possible to establish motherhood in breastfeeding without fatherhood? Meaning that the man has a mother from breastfeeding but no father. He has a mother from breastfeeding but no father. Give the example. The example was not given. So she is the mother and he has no father. Okay, the example is: a woman breastfed a child while she was in the marriage bond with her husband. She breastfed the child three times, then her husband divorced her and she married another, and she became pregnant from him and breastfed the child how many times? Two times. Here she is the mother because she breastfed the child five times, and he does not have a father because he was breastfed from the milk of the first three times and from the milk of the second two times. Conversely, for example, is it possible for there to be a child who has a father from breastfeeding but no mother from breastfeeding? He has a father from breastfeeding but no mother. He has no mother from breastfeeding. Three times, five times, unless you satisfied him. If you satisfied him. Yes. Hurry.
You heard the answer. A man has two wives. One of them breastfed this child twice and the other breastfed him three times. Here he has a father from breastfeeding but no mother from breastfeeding. So his mother, because if we say his first mother, it is not correct because she did not breastfeed him except twice, and if we say the second, she is not his mother because she did not breastfeed him except three times. But the milk is the husband's milk, so the husband is his father from breastfeeding and he has no mother from breastfeeding. No, the condition is not just satisfaction, but that they are separated from each other. The first and second case in which it is established? What do you say about this? If the child has a mother from breastfeeding but no father, do the children of the second and first husband become brothers to the one who has a mother from breastfeeding? The children of the two husbands from the woman who breastfed are brothers from the mother, brothers from the mother. And as for the children of the two husbands from other than the one who breastfed, they are not brothers, they are not brothers. Did you understand? Did you understand, people, or not? Okay.
A man has two wives. A woman breastfed a child at her husband's house two times, then she left him and married another, and breastfed this child three times, so the total breastfeedings became five breastfeedings. Thus, the prohibition is established from the side of the mother. The children of the mother who breastfed the child, whether from the first husband or the second husband, are brothers to the breastfed child from the mother. The children of the two husbands from other than the wet nurse are not brothers, because the fatherhood from breastfeeding was not established for the father, and those who branch off from him follow him. Okay, does the husband's father become a grandfather to the breastfed child? No, because if the fatherhood is not established, what branches off from it is not established. Yes, correct.
The second case: a man has two wives. One of them breastfed this child three times and the other child two times. Motherhood was not established, but fatherhood was established. Accordingly, the children of the husband become brothers to this breastfed child, whether the children are from the two wet-nurse wives or from previous wives. Yes. Forbidden, forbidden, yes.
The questioner : May Allah reward you.
Source
قناة «فضيلة الشيخ محمد بن صالح العثيمين»، 6 - 15 - دروس وفتاوى المسجد الحرام للعام 1412 هـ - الدرس السادس - الشيخ محمد بن صالح العثيمين
youtube.com (1:05:02)
youtube.com (1:05:02)
