The ruling on selling grain for its kind by weight with an increase in exchange for craftsmanship
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question : May Allah bless you. If we increase the weight of the grain that has not been milled, and the increase is in exchange for the work.
Answer : The school of thought does not consider this; what is increased by craftsmanship is not taken into account. This is the closest view: that it is not taken into account. This is because the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) said regarding the good dates that are taken, one sa' for two sa' of the inferior ones, that this is the very essence of riba (usury or interest). So the Messenger (peace and blessings be upon him) prohibited the increase in exchange for the description. However, one could argue that this increase is due to the original nature, unlike what is increased by craftsmanship, which is an increase in human work. But even so, blocking the door is better. Because even if we said that an increase in exchange for craftsmanship is permissible, do we guarantee that the increase in the non-crafted item is exactly equal to the value of the craftsmanship? No, we do not know. They might add more than the value of the craft.
Therefore, we hold that blocking the door is better. It is said: Praise be to Allah, the matter is broad. Sell this gold that is not manufactured, receive the coins, and then buy the manufactured gold. That is, there is nothing wrong with it; the door is open.
Answer : The school of thought does not consider this; what is increased by craftsmanship is not taken into account. This is the closest view: that it is not taken into account. This is because the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) said regarding the good dates that are taken, one sa' for two sa' of the inferior ones, that this is the very essence of riba (usury or interest). So the Messenger (peace and blessings be upon him) prohibited the increase in exchange for the description. However, one could argue that this increase is due to the original nature, unlike what is increased by craftsmanship, which is an increase in human work. But even so, blocking the door is better. Because even if we said that an increase in exchange for craftsmanship is permissible, do we guarantee that the increase in the non-crafted item is exactly equal to the value of the craftsmanship? No, we do not know. They might add more than the value of the craft.
Therefore, we hold that blocking the door is better. It is said: Praise be to Allah, the matter is broad. Sell this gold that is not manufactured, receive the coins, and then buy the manufactured gold. That is, there is nothing wrong with it; the door is open.
Source
قناة «فضيلة الشيخ محمد بن صالح العثيمين»، [4099] حكم بيع الحب بجنسه وزنًا مع الزيادة إلى مقابل الصنعة - تعليقات على الكافي لابن عثيمين
youtube.com
youtube.com
