Does the heir’s lunar year of possession count based on the deceased’s lunar year?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner : The heir does not base his lunar year on the deceased’s lunar year, because it is a new ownership. If he has thirty cows and he acquires ten more,
The Shaykh : I bear witness.
The questioner : Ten.
The Shaykh : Yes. Ten.
The questioner : then he owes a two-year-old cow for the thirty when their lunar year is completed. When the lunar year of the ten is completed, he owes a quarter of a three-year-old cow, because the threshold for a three-year-old cow has been reached, but it was not possible to make it obligatory due to the thirty having its own ruling. Therefore, the ten owe their share of it,
The Shaykh : in my view, the ten owe their share of it. This is what I consider more correct, because the pronoun refers to the feminine, and “ten” is feminine, just like the one before it. So when the lunar year of the ten is completed, and he seeks forgiveness, when the lunar year of the ten is completed,
The questioner : Do you need it recorded? Yes, I say, do you not need it recorded?
The Shaykh : A smooth recording. He said (may Allah have mercy on him): If a person has thirty cows, how many cows does he have? Thirty cows? A two-year-old or a two-year-old? If he acquires ten during the lunar year through a contract such as a gift, if a person is gifted ten cows or his deceased relative leaves him ten cows by inheritance, then he owes a two-year-old cow for the thirty when their lunar year is completed. Is that clear? Good. He owned thirty cows in Muharram, in Jumada al-Ula he owned thirty, ten items. Now he has forty. When does he pay zakah on the thirty?
The questioner : Literally.
The Shaykh : In the second year of prohibition, and he owes a two-year-old or a female two-year-old. And when does he pay zakah on the ten? In Jumada al-Thani, but he owes a quarter of a three-year-old, because in forty there is a three-year-old, and these ten are part of forty, so this is a quarter of a three-year-old. Here, the ten follow the thirty in the threshold, not in the lunar year, in the threshold. Because if they did not follow in the threshold, nothing would be obligatory on them, because they are ten, and there is nothing due on ten. But they follow in the threshold, not in the lunar year. So we say: when the lunar year of the thirty is completed, you owe a two-year-old or a female two-year-old, and nothing is obligatory on you for the ten. When the lunar year of the ten is completed, you owe a quarter of a three-year-old, because now, when their lunar year is completed, or if you add them to the thirty, they become forty, and in forty there is
The questioner : a three-year-old.
The Shaykh : a three-year-old. So you owe a quarter of a three-year-old for the ten.
The questioner : Good. Why does he not pay a three-year-old for the forty? How? Why does he not pay for the forty?
The Shaykh : If he wants to pay a three-year-old by advancing the zakah of the thirty, there is no harm. That is, if he says, “It is no burden for me to look for a quarter of a three-year-old. I want to pay a full three-year-old now for the forty,” and for the thirty,
The questioner : it is advanced.
The Shaykh : Advancing it is fine. No, no. For the thirty, do you want us to advance it based on the lunar year of the thirty, or based on the lunar year of the forty?
The questioner : The lunar year of the thirty.
The Shaykh : Then it does not contradict. It will be a three-year-old, and it will be advanced for the ten. But if he wants to delay it, and when the zakah becomes obligatory on the ten, he says, “I have no need to go to the trouble of looking for a quarter of a three-year-old. I want to pay a full three-year-old now for the forty,” we say there is no harm, and this is from the category of advancing payment.
The Shaykh : I bear witness.
The questioner : Ten.
The Shaykh : Yes. Ten.
The questioner : then he owes a two-year-old cow for the thirty when their lunar year is completed. When the lunar year of the ten is completed, he owes a quarter of a three-year-old cow, because the threshold for a three-year-old cow has been reached, but it was not possible to make it obligatory due to the thirty having its own ruling. Therefore, the ten owe their share of it,
The Shaykh : in my view, the ten owe their share of it. This is what I consider more correct, because the pronoun refers to the feminine, and “ten” is feminine, just like the one before it. So when the lunar year of the ten is completed, and he seeks forgiveness, when the lunar year of the ten is completed,
The questioner : Do you need it recorded? Yes, I say, do you not need it recorded?
The Shaykh : A smooth recording. He said (may Allah have mercy on him): If a person has thirty cows, how many cows does he have? Thirty cows? A two-year-old or a two-year-old? If he acquires ten during the lunar year through a contract such as a gift, if a person is gifted ten cows or his deceased relative leaves him ten cows by inheritance, then he owes a two-year-old cow for the thirty when their lunar year is completed. Is that clear? Good. He owned thirty cows in Muharram, in Jumada al-Ula he owned thirty, ten items. Now he has forty. When does he pay zakah on the thirty?
The questioner : Literally.
The Shaykh : In the second year of prohibition, and he owes a two-year-old or a female two-year-old. And when does he pay zakah on the ten? In Jumada al-Thani, but he owes a quarter of a three-year-old, because in forty there is a three-year-old, and these ten are part of forty, so this is a quarter of a three-year-old. Here, the ten follow the thirty in the threshold, not in the lunar year, in the threshold. Because if they did not follow in the threshold, nothing would be obligatory on them, because they are ten, and there is nothing due on ten. But they follow in the threshold, not in the lunar year. So we say: when the lunar year of the thirty is completed, you owe a two-year-old or a female two-year-old, and nothing is obligatory on you for the ten. When the lunar year of the ten is completed, you owe a quarter of a three-year-old, because now, when their lunar year is completed, or if you add them to the thirty, they become forty, and in forty there is
The questioner : a three-year-old.
The Shaykh : a three-year-old. So you owe a quarter of a three-year-old for the ten.
The questioner : Good. Why does he not pay a three-year-old for the forty? How? Why does he not pay for the forty?
The Shaykh : If he wants to pay a three-year-old by advancing the zakah of the thirty, there is no harm. That is, if he says, “It is no burden for me to look for a quarter of a three-year-old. I want to pay a full three-year-old now for the forty,” and for the thirty,
The questioner : it is advanced.
The Shaykh : Advancing it is fine. No, no. For the thirty, do you want us to advance it based on the lunar year of the thirty, or based on the lunar year of the forty?
The questioner : The lunar year of the thirty.
The Shaykh : Then it does not contradict. It will be a three-year-old, and it will be advanced for the ten. But if he wants to delay it, and when the zakah becomes obligatory on the ten, he says, “I have no need to go to the trouble of looking for a quarter of a three-year-old. I want to pay a full three-year-old now for the forty,” we say there is no harm, and this is from the category of advancing payment.
Source
قناة «فضيلة الشيخ محمد بن صالح العثيمين»، 2446 - هل يبنى حول الوارث على حول الموروث؟ الكافي في فقه الإمام أحمد بن حنبل - ابن عثيمين
youtube.com
youtube.com
