If a man wipes over boots, then removes the boots and wipes over socks, is his wiping valid, or is he required to wash his feet?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner : Shaykh, may Allah reward you. Here is a matter in this book: A man wipes over boots the first time, and the second time he removes the boots and wipes over socks. Is his wiping valid, or is he required to wash his feet? Here, may Allah reward you, it seems you have held the position that it is permissible to wipe over socks?
The Shaykh : If, if.
The questioner : The answer is that there is scholarly disagreement on this. Some scholars hold that if one wipes over the upper or lower of the two khuffayn (leather socks), the ruling attaches to that one and does not transfer to the other. Others hold that it is permissible to transfer to the second as long as the time period remains. For example, if he wipes over boots, then removes them and wants to perform wudu' (ablution), he may wipe over the socks, which are the sharab, according to the stronger opinion. Likewise, if he wipes over socks and then wears other socks or boots over them and wipes over the upper ones, there is no harm in that according to the stronger opinion, as long as the time period remains. However, the time period is calculated from the first wiping, not the second wiping. This is it.
The Shaykh : This is what we said we wanted an opinion on. I found a disagreement, so if there is a disagreement, then the stronger opinion.
The questioner : What are all the schools of jurisprudence based on, O Shaykh?
The Shaykh : That if he removes the upper khuff (leather sock) that he wiped over, it is permissible for him to wipe over the lower one. We say that the disagreement is established if there is a disagreement, meaning that if there is a disagreement, the two khuffayn become in the position of a single khuff. Just as if a person wipes over a sewn khuff that has a back and a front, and then removes the back, he wipes over the front. On this view, the two khuffayn are as if they are one single khuff.
The Shaykh : If, if.
The questioner : The answer is that there is scholarly disagreement on this. Some scholars hold that if one wipes over the upper or lower of the two khuffayn (leather socks), the ruling attaches to that one and does not transfer to the other. Others hold that it is permissible to transfer to the second as long as the time period remains. For example, if he wipes over boots, then removes them and wants to perform wudu' (ablution), he may wipe over the socks, which are the sharab, according to the stronger opinion. Likewise, if he wipes over socks and then wears other socks or boots over them and wipes over the upper ones, there is no harm in that according to the stronger opinion, as long as the time period remains. However, the time period is calculated from the first wiping, not the second wiping. This is it.
The Shaykh : This is what we said we wanted an opinion on. I found a disagreement, so if there is a disagreement, then the stronger opinion.
The questioner : What are all the schools of jurisprudence based on, O Shaykh?
The Shaykh : That if he removes the upper khuff (leather sock) that he wiped over, it is permissible for him to wipe over the lower one. We say that the disagreement is established if there is a disagreement, meaning that if there is a disagreement, the two khuffayn become in the position of a single khuff. Just as if a person wipes over a sewn khuff that has a back and a front, and then removes the back, he wipes over the front. On this view, the two khuffayn are as if they are one single khuff.
Source
قناة «فضيلة الشيخ محمد بن صالح العثيمين»، 320 - إذا مسح الرجل على الكنادر ثم خلع الكنادر ومسح على الشراب فهل يصح مسحه أم لابد من غسل الرجل؟
youtube.com
youtube.com
