What is the ruling on shaking the head when reciting the Qur'an?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner : I saw the late professor, I saw the late professor, what? I say that the unity had degrees during the recitation.
The Shaykh : Yes, meaning if he found something he liked, he would say "Subhan Allah" (Glory be to Allah) or something similar, and he would affirm it with his head like this, is that what you mean?
The questioner : No, always.
The Shaykh : Or, for example, the one who stands and says this. Yes, what is your opinion on this?
The questioner : I know that Radwan narrated to us that he studied this, that this harms the vision because he does it in a certain way.
The Shaykh : What does he do?
The questioner : I say the end of the way of visions by looking.
The Shaykh : It harms the vision?
The questioner : That when a person comes to a name like this, the image enlarges and shrinks for him, so I think it is a lot of looking.
The Shaykh : And he stays up reading from memory, by heart.
The questioner : Meaning he puts out a stick from behind. O Amir. This person, if it is normal, Subhan Allah, if one does a thing and does not feel that he...
The Shaykh : It appears that it comes without choice from some people, and some people, if they wanted, could prevent themselves from doing it while reading, it does not go on, so if a person gets used to it, he cannot let it go, but is it better to get used to it? Some people say that it is better not to get used to it because this is from the ways of the Sufis. The Sufis, when they remember Allah (Mighty and Majestic) with certain dhikr (remembrance), they shake, and the more the dhikr has an impact on their hearts, the more they lower themselves. Some of them would have a whip with them and strike the ground with it, so if the dust rose more, his reward would be more, and this is what they call "tagheer" (raising dust). They have a dhikr of change, this is known, they give each person a voice saying "come on, when we reach the end of the sentence, strike." If there is more dust, it means that he has a stronger emotion, he has a stronger emotion in this dhikr than others, so it appears that the one who said among the people that it is not befitting to shake out of fear of imitation (tashabbuh). But if it is a natural matter, meaning nature imposes it and he cannot get rid of it, it appears that, if Allah wills, there is no harm in it. But there are people who appear to me to be intentional about this, they are intentional, and for this reason, some of them you find holding his ears like this, then he shakes once, once, until he reaches close to the ground, this means that he is intentional about this thing,
The Shaykh : Yes, meaning if he found something he liked, he would say "Subhan Allah" (Glory be to Allah) or something similar, and he would affirm it with his head like this, is that what you mean?
The questioner : No, always.
The Shaykh : Or, for example, the one who stands and says this. Yes, what is your opinion on this?
The questioner : I know that Radwan narrated to us that he studied this, that this harms the vision because he does it in a certain way.
The Shaykh : What does he do?
The questioner : I say the end of the way of visions by looking.
The Shaykh : It harms the vision?
The questioner : That when a person comes to a name like this, the image enlarges and shrinks for him, so I think it is a lot of looking.
The Shaykh : And he stays up reading from memory, by heart.
The questioner : Meaning he puts out a stick from behind. O Amir. This person, if it is normal, Subhan Allah, if one does a thing and does not feel that he...
The Shaykh : It appears that it comes without choice from some people, and some people, if they wanted, could prevent themselves from doing it while reading, it does not go on, so if a person gets used to it, he cannot let it go, but is it better to get used to it? Some people say that it is better not to get used to it because this is from the ways of the Sufis. The Sufis, when they remember Allah (Mighty and Majestic) with certain dhikr (remembrance), they shake, and the more the dhikr has an impact on their hearts, the more they lower themselves. Some of them would have a whip with them and strike the ground with it, so if the dust rose more, his reward would be more, and this is what they call "tagheer" (raising dust). They have a dhikr of change, this is known, they give each person a voice saying "come on, when we reach the end of the sentence, strike." If there is more dust, it means that he has a stronger emotion, he has a stronger emotion in this dhikr than others, so it appears that the one who said among the people that it is not befitting to shake out of fear of imitation (tashabbuh). But if it is a natural matter, meaning nature imposes it and he cannot get rid of it, it appears that, if Allah wills, there is no harm in it. But there are people who appear to me to be intentional about this, they are intentional, and for this reason, some of them you find holding his ears like this, then he shakes once, once, until he reaches close to the ground, this means that he is intentional about this thing,
Source
قناة «فضيلة الشيخ محمد بن صالح العثيمين»، 1848 - 4600 ما حكم هز الرأس عند تلاوة القرآن؟ ابن عثيمين
youtube.com
youtube.com
