Is it permissible to take what the judge has ruled in one's favor, knowing that one does not deserve it?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner : It is obligatory for the judge to rule; he must rule.
The Shaykh : There is no problem.
The presenter : Thank you.
The Shaykh : And what is in it? They resort to him for judgment, but one does not take anything but the right. That is to say, if he rules in favor of one contrary to the right, he does not take it.
The questioner : He is a harsh, harsh al-Hasan, and a defender of pressure, meaning a defender of pressure?
The Shaykh : This sin is upon the lawyer.
The questioner : Listen, O Muhammad, but listen, listen.
The Shaykh : The judge is digging [a pit] with the sin, because he does not judge according to what he hears.
The presenter : And I answer your share.
The Shaykh : Yes, we keep people occupied. Therefore, Ibn al-Qayyim’s words on the methods of judgment are good. He said: People cannot be left without resorting to judgment if there is no one to judge by the Shari'ah, so they resort to them. But what contradicts the Shari'ah is not to be followed.
The questioner : Some people try to go to rights, then, meaning, they abandon their rights.
The Shaykh : No, that is a mistake. The judge is not bound except by what the condition indicates.
The questioner : If they condition upon them a judge who judges by other than the Shari'ah, he says: If you are going to resort to me for judgment, you must accept my ruling, whether it agrees with the Shari'ah or contradicts it. Do they enter into the judgment with me?
The Shaykh : He contradicts if he says this and rules in my favor with what I do not deserve, meaning after I heard my opponent's arguments, I acknowledged that the right is with him. So here, if he rules in my favor, I say to my companion: It is yours.
The questioner : Yes, this is with the purity of hearts, but with the state of people today, everyone takes the right of the other.
The Shaykh : This is the one who deceives the right of the other; he will resort even to the just judge and try with all his ability to mislead the judge. Yes, originally, may Allah bless you, you are not at ease as a judge except that you want to take your right. And this judge who judges by other than what Allah has revealed may judge by what Allah has revealed even if he does not intend it, and he may judge by other than what Allah has revealed. If he judges by other than what Allah has revealed, he has wronged you, and the sin is upon him.
The questioner : No, no, absolutely not, I do not relinquish it as long as it is there.
The Shaykh : Yes.
The questioner : And what about silence?
The Shaykh : He does not contradict; this would be an injustice he is bound to out of fear of his injustice. That is all, it is finished.
The presenter : How is the market of life going?
The Shaykh : Yes, a sign from whom? Because these leaders show people the appearance of knowledge. Do you understand? They appear to be scholars, but they are ignorant. He says.
The Shaykh : There is no problem.
The presenter : Thank you.
The Shaykh : And what is in it? They resort to him for judgment, but one does not take anything but the right. That is to say, if he rules in favor of one contrary to the right, he does not take it.
The questioner : He is a harsh, harsh al-Hasan, and a defender of pressure, meaning a defender of pressure?
The Shaykh : This sin is upon the lawyer.
The questioner : Listen, O Muhammad, but listen, listen.
The Shaykh : The judge is digging [a pit] with the sin, because he does not judge according to what he hears.
The presenter : And I answer your share.
The Shaykh : Yes, we keep people occupied. Therefore, Ibn al-Qayyim’s words on the methods of judgment are good. He said: People cannot be left without resorting to judgment if there is no one to judge by the Shari'ah, so they resort to them. But what contradicts the Shari'ah is not to be followed.
The questioner : Some people try to go to rights, then, meaning, they abandon their rights.
The Shaykh : No, that is a mistake. The judge is not bound except by what the condition indicates.
The questioner : If they condition upon them a judge who judges by other than the Shari'ah, he says: If you are going to resort to me for judgment, you must accept my ruling, whether it agrees with the Shari'ah or contradicts it. Do they enter into the judgment with me?
The Shaykh : He contradicts if he says this and rules in my favor with what I do not deserve, meaning after I heard my opponent's arguments, I acknowledged that the right is with him. So here, if he rules in my favor, I say to my companion: It is yours.
The questioner : Yes, this is with the purity of hearts, but with the state of people today, everyone takes the right of the other.
The Shaykh : This is the one who deceives the right of the other; he will resort even to the just judge and try with all his ability to mislead the judge. Yes, originally, may Allah bless you, you are not at ease as a judge except that you want to take your right. And this judge who judges by other than what Allah has revealed may judge by what Allah has revealed even if he does not intend it, and he may judge by other than what Allah has revealed. If he judges by other than what Allah has revealed, he has wronged you, and the sin is upon him.
The questioner : No, no, absolutely not, I do not relinquish it as long as it is there.
The Shaykh : Yes.
The questioner : And what about silence?
The Shaykh : He does not contradict; this would be an injustice he is bound to out of fear of his injustice. That is all, it is finished.
The presenter : How is the market of life going?
The Shaykh : Yes, a sign from whom? Because these leaders show people the appearance of knowledge. Do you understand? They appear to be scholars, but they are ignorant. He says.
Source
قناة «فضيلة الشيخ محمد بن صالح العثيمين»، 589- هل يجوز أن يأخذ ما حكم له به القاضي وهو يعلم أنه لا يستحقه؟ - ابن عثيمين
youtube.com
youtube.com
