Is it permissible to conquer Makkah if the same situation that occurred at the conquest of Makkah were to happen?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner : Our speech, O Shaykh al-Islam. Yes. The story of Salim, the freed slave of Hudhayfah.
The Shaykh : Abu Hudhayfah. I.
The questioner : When it appeared that way in the code of Ibn Iyad, when the slaughter was done before the prayer, it became clear that the Shari'ah does not specify a particular individual for something, yes, but it specifies a state. This hadith: the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) made Makkah a sanctuary. If it were said that if the same situation occurred, meaning Makkah fell into the hands of the polytheists, yes, and then the event happened and the Muslims wanted to conquer it from the idols and shirk (associating partners with Allah) that is mentioned with this limit.
The Shaykh : No, because the Messenger of Allah denied that. He said: Close the door. And in his saying, "There is no migration after the conquest," there is glad tidings that Makkah will not return to being a house of disbelief.
The Shaykh : Abu Hudhayfah. I.
The questioner : When it appeared that way in the code of Ibn Iyad, when the slaughter was done before the prayer, it became clear that the Shari'ah does not specify a particular individual for something, yes, but it specifies a state. This hadith: the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) made Makkah a sanctuary. If it were said that if the same situation occurred, meaning Makkah fell into the hands of the polytheists, yes, and then the event happened and the Muslims wanted to conquer it from the idols and shirk (associating partners with Allah) that is mentioned with this limit.
The Shaykh : No, because the Messenger of Allah denied that. He said:
If anyone takes the liberty of fighting the Messenger of Allah, say: "Allah has given permission to His Messenger, but He has not given permission to you."
إن أحد ترخص بقتال رسول الله فقولوا إن الله أذن لكم لرسوله ولم يأذن لكم
Source
قناة «فضيلة الشيخ محمد بن صالح العثيمين»، 223 - 4600 هل يجوز أن تستحل مكة إذا وقع لها نفس الحالة التي حدثت عند فتح مكة؟ ابن عثيمين
youtube.com
youtube.com
