Some pilgrims on the eleventh day appoint a proxy for the following day and then travel. What is the ruling?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question : After the pilgrims on the eleventh day, they appoint a proxy for the day after that, the day after that, and then they travel.
Answer : What does it equal? What? The day after that and the day after that. Yes. We say it is easier and more convenient for them to appoint a proxy for standing at 'Arafah, staying at Muzdalifah, spending the night in Mina, stoning the pillars, the tawaf of ifadah, and sa'y, and then walk. What is easier?
Did he not perform Hajj? The truth is that the action of some people in Hajj is like playing around, as if they are on a picnic, returning whenever they wish and staying whenever they wish. The pilgrim must remain until the twelfth day, and it is not permissible to appoint a proxy for spending the night, nor is it permissible to appoint a proxy for stoning the pillars except in cases of dire necessity. So their action is wrong. And although the rule among the jurists is that they are sinful, and that they are required to pay two ransom payments, one for the stoning and one for spending the night, the whole matter is that this is playing around. Yes, if a person suffers harm, meaning dire necessity, and wants to travel, such as being struck by an illness that prevents him from staying, or something similar of necessary things, then at that time we say there is no harm in his leaving. He appoints a proxy for what is valid for proxy appointment, and pays a ransom for what is not valid for proxy appointment.
Answer : What does it equal? What? The day after that and the day after that. Yes. We say it is easier and more convenient for them to appoint a proxy for standing at 'Arafah, staying at Muzdalifah, spending the night in Mina, stoning the pillars, the tawaf of ifadah, and sa'y, and then walk. What is easier?
Did he not perform Hajj? The truth is that the action of some people in Hajj is like playing around, as if they are on a picnic, returning whenever they wish and staying whenever they wish. The pilgrim must remain until the twelfth day, and it is not permissible to appoint a proxy for spending the night, nor is it permissible to appoint a proxy for stoning the pillars except in cases of dire necessity. So their action is wrong. And although the rule among the jurists is that they are sinful, and that they are required to pay two ransom payments, one for the stoning and one for spending the night, the whole matter is that this is playing around. Yes, if a person suffers harm, meaning dire necessity, and wants to travel, such as being struck by an illness that prevents him from staying, or something similar of necessary things, then at that time we say there is no harm in his leaving. He appoints a proxy for what is valid for proxy appointment, and pays a ransom for what is not valid for proxy appointment.
Source
قناة «فضيلة الشيخ محمد بن صالح العثيمين»، 206 - بعض الحجاج في اليوم الحادي عشر يوكلون عن اليوم الذي بعده ويسافرون فما الحكم؟
youtube.com
youtube.com
