The ruling on initiating the salam with one who has not greeted, and the rulings on returning the salam
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner : After [the opening], Honorable Shaykh, may Allah reward you. The questioner says: Sometimes people pass by us and do not greet us. Is it permissible for us to initiate the salam with them, and is there any advice for these people?
The Shaykh : Glory be to Allah and praise be to Him, Glory be to Allah the Most Great. These are two words that are light on the tongue, heavy in the scale, and beloved to the Most Merciful. How fitting it is for us to make our tongues constantly utter these two words. Glory be to Allah and praise be to Him, Glory be to Allah the Most Great. I say, Glory be to Allah and praise be to Him, Glory be to Allah the Most Great, in astonishment, in astonishment at the state of many Muslims whom Allah has blessed with this good, blessed greeting, which is offering the salam. Offering the salam is a right of a Muslim over his brother when he meets him. It is one of the characteristics of Muslims, one of the noble traits, one of the causes of increasing faith, and one of the causes of entering Paradise. Listen to the words of Muhammad, the Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings be upon him). He swore, and he is the truthful, the pious, without needing to swear, and he said: "By Allah, you will not enter Paradise until you believe." And the Messenger (peace and blessings be upon him) is truthful. O Allah, make faith firm in our hearts. "By Allah, you will not enter Paradise until you believe, and you will not believe until you love one another." Until your heart loves your brother, even if he wrongs you. "Shall I not inform you, or did he say, shall I not direct you, to something that if you do it, you will love one another? Spread the salam among you." That means, disseminate the salam, display it, and announce it among yourselves. And yet, many Muslims today pass by you and do not greet you. And you pass by them and do not greet them. This is a mistake; this is contrary to the characteristics of Muslims. It is a great practice among the practices of Islam. It is a sound methodology from the methodologies of Muslims, which is the salam.
And yet, if I say to my brother when I pass by him, "Peace be upon you," how many dirhams do you get? You do not get a dirham, but you get ten good deeds, which you will find you need most on the Day of Resurrection, and you will have ten good deeds remaining. I think if I told you that whoever greets me, I will give him five riyals, I would find one of you greeting me before he passes me, and when he passes me, and when he turns his back to me, then he would come back a second time to earn the first one. How much did he earn? Not fifteen riyals, because I only gave him five, and the second time when he came back, he earned fifteen riyals, meaning thirty, and so on. He would start circling around me as the millstone circles, because he wants to earn riyals. But ten good deeds remain for you, and by Allah, you will need them most, yet you do not care about them. Glory be to Allah. Then, what the salam begets of love between the Muslim and the Muslim is something undeniable. It is undeniable. If a person passes by you and greets you, you love him. And if you greet him, he loves you. So why do we deny this great blessing, and one of us passes by his brother without greeting him?
But if he does not greet you, do you greet him? Yes, my brother, yes, I greet him. And our Prophet Muhammad (peace and blessings be upon him) would initiate the salam with whoever he met. He is the one who initiates, even though the right belongs to him, and the right is that people initiate the salam, but he does not; he initiates the salam. He would greet even the young ones; he would pass by the children and greet them. Allah is the Greatest. And he (peace and blessings be upon him) said:Sahih al-Bukhari 6077 So the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) forbade a Muslim to boycott his brother, and he indicated that the one who initiates the salam is the better of the two. So why do we not initiate? Some of the Salaf would go down to the market to pass by the people and greet them, because there are many people in the market, so he would greet them. Why? To increase his good deeds. O my brothers, by Allah, if a person had a bag in his pocket, and every time he greeted someone, he gave a dirham, and he filled it and was eager, how much more so with good deeds? I urge my Muslim brothers in this place, in this noble place, in this noble matter, to spread the salam among themselves and not to be weary or bored of it. Even if you catch up to your brother and overtake him, if you are alongside him, what do you do? Greet him. That means, the meeting is such that it is clear you greeted him, but even if you pass by him and overtake him, greet him, so that there is love.
Now, how do you say the salam? Some people say, "Welcome." And "Fakh mab'ud" (a phrase of welcome) fills his mouth with it. Does this suffice or not? It does not suffice. One must say, "Peace be upon you," or "Salam 'alaykum." As for "Welcome" or "Ahlan," you do not understand. Well, he greeted him and said, "Welcome and easy, may my father be with you. This is a joyful day. I am happy to meet you. May Allah welcome you and bid you welcome. Be assured of good hospitality at our place. We have kabsa and shahi." Yes, does this suffice or not? It does not suffice. And what suffices from this? That he says, "Peace be upon you." That he says, "Peace be upon you." As for whatever he fills the air with of glorification, of welcoming the person and greeting him, it is not enough. But unfortunately, now some people think that the word "Welcome" is enough, but it is not. Well, the one who greeted his brother and said to him, "Welcome," does the one who responds sin or not?
He sins. He sins, because returning the salam is an individual obligation (fard 'ayn) on the one who was greeted. An individual obligation. If I greet you, it is not obligatory for you to return the salam. Well, if you enter a gathering of people, and with them, for example, is an emir, or a minister, or a president, or a scholar, and you greet, and the first one you intend is this elder, and the group all return the salam except the elder, does the elder sin or not? He sins. Yes, because he is the first one intended by the salam. But if they are equal, and you greet, and one of them returns it, that suffices, because returning the salam is a collective obligation (fard kifayah), and it is an individual obligation (fard 'ayn) on the one who was intended. Pay attention to this, my brother. Pay attention to this. Actions are by intentions. Among people now, and this happened recently, and we did not know it before, when a person enters the gathering, he starts with the first person on his right, shakes his hand, and goes through all the people until he forces them to stand up, and they are reluctant to do so for him. And I did not know this practice from the Messenger (peace and blessings be upon him) or from the Companions. For this reason, when the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) would enter, the Companions would not stand up for him, because they knew that he disliked that. So is it conceivable that if the Messenger entered and extended his hand to greet, that one of the Companions would greet him while he is sitting? It is not possible. They must stand up. So it is known from that that it is not the way of the Messenger (peace and blessings be upon him) that when he enters a gathering, he starts shaking hands from the right, even if it is the youngest of the people, and then goes through them. Rather, if a person sees that it is necessary to greet, because he is coming from a journey, for example, then here he starts with the eldest. He starts with the eldest of those in the gathering, based on the saying of the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him), "The elder, the elder," and he ordered the one who brought water to give it to start with the eldest. Then the one on the right of the person entering. He is on the right of the eldest, because when a person faces the eldest, the one on his right is the one on the left of the eldest, and the Sunnah is to start with the right. You start with them, the rightmost, then the rightmost, until you reach the end of the seated people, then you start with the one on the left of the eldest. This is what I know from the Sunnah. And I advise my brothers in such general, comprehensive matters to first verify from the Sunnah and then act upon it. And if someone comes across something that contradicts what I said now, let him present it to me, for I will be grateful to him. But this is what I know from the Sunnah of the Messenger (peace and blessings be upon him). Well, if you enter and greet, where do you sit? You sit at the end of the gathering. If someone volunteers his place for me, there is no blame on me for sitting in it. And if there is a place prepared for me by the youngest, I advance to it and sit in it. Otherwise, I do not force people to stand up from their places until I sit. Sit where the gathering ends for you. If you are of honor, the seated people will make the front of the gathering where you are, even if you are the last of the people. And whoever does not honor himself is not honored. The important thing is that this issue came, so to speak, as an aside, but the important thing, my brothers, is to spread the salam among you. Make your community an Islamic community with affection, love, gentleness, and softness. The salam is a reward for you, and affection among you, and a realization of your faith, and a cause for your entry into Paradise. Yes.
The Shaykh : Glory be to Allah and praise be to Him, Glory be to Allah the Most Great. These are two words that are light on the tongue, heavy in the scale, and beloved to the Most Merciful. How fitting it is for us to make our tongues constantly utter these two words. Glory be to Allah and praise be to Him, Glory be to Allah the Most Great. I say, Glory be to Allah and praise be to Him, Glory be to Allah the Most Great, in astonishment, in astonishment at the state of many Muslims whom Allah has blessed with this good, blessed greeting, which is offering the salam. Offering the salam is a right of a Muslim over his brother when he meets him. It is one of the characteristics of Muslims, one of the noble traits, one of the causes of increasing faith, and one of the causes of entering Paradise. Listen to the words of Muhammad, the Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings be upon him). He swore, and he is the truthful, the pious, without needing to swear, and he said: "By Allah, you will not enter Paradise until you believe." And the Messenger (peace and blessings be upon him) is truthful. O Allah, make faith firm in our hearts. "By Allah, you will not enter Paradise until you believe, and you will not believe until you love one another." Until your heart loves your brother, even if he wrongs you. "Shall I not inform you, or did he say, shall I not direct you, to something that if you do it, you will love one another? Spread the salam among you." That means, disseminate the salam, display it, and announce it among yourselves. And yet, many Muslims today pass by you and do not greet you. And you pass by them and do not greet them. This is a mistake; this is contrary to the characteristics of Muslims. It is a great practice among the practices of Islam. It is a sound methodology from the methodologies of Muslims, which is the salam.
And yet, if I say to my brother when I pass by him, "Peace be upon you," how many dirhams do you get? You do not get a dirham, but you get ten good deeds, which you will find you need most on the Day of Resurrection, and you will have ten good deeds remaining. I think if I told you that whoever greets me, I will give him five riyals, I would find one of you greeting me before he passes me, and when he passes me, and when he turns his back to me, then he would come back a second time to earn the first one. How much did he earn? Not fifteen riyals, because I only gave him five, and the second time when he came back, he earned fifteen riyals, meaning thirty, and so on. He would start circling around me as the millstone circles, because he wants to earn riyals. But ten good deeds remain for you, and by Allah, you will need them most, yet you do not care about them. Glory be to Allah. Then, what the salam begets of love between the Muslim and the Muslim is something undeniable. It is undeniable. If a person passes by you and greets you, you love him. And if you greet him, he loves you. So why do we deny this great blessing, and one of us passes by his brother without greeting him?
But if he does not greet you, do you greet him? Yes, my brother, yes, I greet him. And our Prophet Muhammad (peace and blessings be upon him) would initiate the salam with whoever he met. He is the one who initiates, even though the right belongs to him, and the right is that people initiate the salam, but he does not; he initiates the salam. He would greet even the young ones; he would pass by the children and greet them. Allah is the Greatest. And he (peace and blessings be upon him) said:
It is not lawful for a man to desert his brother Muslim for more than three nights. (It is unlawful for them that) when they meet, one of them turns his face away from the other, and the other turns his face from the former, and the better of the two will be the one who greets the other first.
لا يحل لرجل أن يهجر أخاه فوق ثلاث يلتقيان فيعرض هذا ويعرض هذا، وخيرهما الذي يبدأ بالسلامNow, how do you say the salam? Some people say, "Welcome." And "Fakh mab'ud" (a phrase of welcome) fills his mouth with it. Does this suffice or not? It does not suffice. One must say, "Peace be upon you," or "Salam 'alaykum." As for "Welcome" or "Ahlan," you do not understand. Well, he greeted him and said, "Welcome and easy, may my father be with you. This is a joyful day. I am happy to meet you. May Allah welcome you and bid you welcome. Be assured of good hospitality at our place. We have kabsa and shahi." Yes, does this suffice or not? It does not suffice. And what suffices from this? That he says, "Peace be upon you." That he says, "Peace be upon you." As for whatever he fills the air with of glorification, of welcoming the person and greeting him, it is not enough. But unfortunately, now some people think that the word "Welcome" is enough, but it is not. Well, the one who greeted his brother and said to him, "Welcome," does the one who responds sin or not?
He sins. He sins, because returning the salam is an individual obligation (fard 'ayn) on the one who was greeted. An individual obligation. If I greet you, it is not obligatory for you to return the salam. Well, if you enter a gathering of people, and with them, for example, is an emir, or a minister, or a president, or a scholar, and you greet, and the first one you intend is this elder, and the group all return the salam except the elder, does the elder sin or not? He sins. Yes, because he is the first one intended by the salam. But if they are equal, and you greet, and one of them returns it, that suffices, because returning the salam is a collective obligation (fard kifayah), and it is an individual obligation (fard 'ayn) on the one who was intended. Pay attention to this, my brother. Pay attention to this. Actions are by intentions. Among people now, and this happened recently, and we did not know it before, when a person enters the gathering, he starts with the first person on his right, shakes his hand, and goes through all the people until he forces them to stand up, and they are reluctant to do so for him. And I did not know this practice from the Messenger (peace and blessings be upon him) or from the Companions. For this reason, when the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) would enter, the Companions would not stand up for him, because they knew that he disliked that. So is it conceivable that if the Messenger entered and extended his hand to greet, that one of the Companions would greet him while he is sitting? It is not possible. They must stand up. So it is known from that that it is not the way of the Messenger (peace and blessings be upon him) that when he enters a gathering, he starts shaking hands from the right, even if it is the youngest of the people, and then goes through them. Rather, if a person sees that it is necessary to greet, because he is coming from a journey, for example, then here he starts with the eldest. He starts with the eldest of those in the gathering, based on the saying of the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him), "The elder, the elder," and he ordered the one who brought water to give it to start with the eldest. Then the one on the right of the person entering. He is on the right of the eldest, because when a person faces the eldest, the one on his right is the one on the left of the eldest, and the Sunnah is to start with the right. You start with them, the rightmost, then the rightmost, until you reach the end of the seated people, then you start with the one on the left of the eldest. This is what I know from the Sunnah. And I advise my brothers in such general, comprehensive matters to first verify from the Sunnah and then act upon it. And if someone comes across something that contradicts what I said now, let him present it to me, for I will be grateful to him. But this is what I know from the Sunnah of the Messenger (peace and blessings be upon him). Well, if you enter and greet, where do you sit? You sit at the end of the gathering. If someone volunteers his place for me, there is no blame on me for sitting in it. And if there is a place prepared for me by the youngest, I advance to it and sit in it. Otherwise, I do not force people to stand up from their places until I sit. Sit where the gathering ends for you. If you are of honor, the seated people will make the front of the gathering where you are, even if you are the last of the people. And whoever does not honor himself is not honored. The important thing is that this issue came, so to speak, as an aside, but the important thing, my brothers, is to spread the salam among you. Make your community an Islamic community with affection, love, gentleness, and softness. The salam is a reward for you, and affection among you, and a realization of your faith, and a cause for your entry into Paradise. Yes.
Source
قناة «فضيلة الشيخ محمد بن صالح العثيمين»، 14 - 41- دروس وفتاوى المسجد الحرام للعام 1419 هـ - الدرس الرابع عشر - الشيخ محمد بن صالح العثيمين
youtube.com (39:18)
youtube.com (39:18)
