If one vows to perform i'tikaf (spiritual retreat in the mosque) in a mosque other than the three mosques, is it obligatory for him?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question : If one vows to perform i'tikaf (spiritual retreat in the mosque) in a mosque other than the three mosques, is it obligatory for him?
Answer : The apparent meaning of the author's statement is that it is not obligatory for him, even if the mosque in which he vowed to perform i'tikaf is distinguished by a specific feature. However, the correct view is that if it is distinguished by a feature, it becomes specific to that mosque. If it is distinguished by a feature, meaning by a virtue, it becomes specific to it, and it is not permissible to perform i'tikaf in another. For example, if it is distinguished by a large congregation, this is a matter intended by the Shari'ah; the larger the congregation, the better. Or if it is distinguished by being older, because age is a feature and a virtue, as the older the mosque, the more worship and devotion to Allah the Exalted has taken place in it. Or if it is distinguished by being a Friday mosque.
Therefore, one does not move to a mosque where Friday prayer is not held, because the Friday mosque is better. The important point is that if one vows to perform i'tikaf in a mosque other than the three mosques, and it is not distinguished by anything, or if he moves from one that is not distinguished to one that is distinguished, there is no harm in that. However, moving from a distinguished mosque to one of lower status is not permissible.
Answer : The apparent meaning of the author's statement is that it is not obligatory for him, even if the mosque in which he vowed to perform i'tikaf is distinguished by a specific feature. However, the correct view is that if it is distinguished by a feature, it becomes specific to that mosque. If it is distinguished by a feature, meaning by a virtue, it becomes specific to it, and it is not permissible to perform i'tikaf in another. For example, if it is distinguished by a large congregation, this is a matter intended by the Shari'ah; the larger the congregation, the better. Or if it is distinguished by being older, because age is a feature and a virtue, as the older the mosque, the more worship and devotion to Allah the Exalted has taken place in it. Or if it is distinguished by being a Friday mosque.
Therefore, one does not move to a mosque where Friday prayer is not held, because the Friday mosque is better. The important point is that if one vows to perform i'tikaf in a mosque other than the three mosques, and it is not distinguished by anything, or if he moves from one that is not distinguished to one that is distinguished, there is no harm in that. However, moving from a distinguished mosque to one of lower status is not permissible.
Source
قناة «فضيلة الشيخ محمد بن صالح العثيمين»، 2316 - إذا نذر الاعتكاف في مسجد غير المساجد الثلاثة فهل يلزمه؟ ابن عثيمين
youtube.com
youtube.com
