Is the prayer valid behind an imam whom we dislike, and he knows that the ma'mum (those praying behind him) dislike him, and is his prayer valid?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question : Is the prayer valid? I said: an imam whom I dislike, and he knows that the ma'mum dislike him, and is his prayer valid?
Answer : First, it must be known that dislike is either religious, meaning they dislike him for his religion, or personal. As for personal dislike, a person must, to the best of his ability, remove it from his heart, and not harbor anything toward his Muslim brothers except love, affection, and closeness. As for religious dislike, one must look at the imam's condition. If he is in a state where his religion is not acceptable, he should not be an imam for the Muslims, such as if his conduct is bad, for example, or if he is known for engaging in more riba (usury or interest) or similar forbidden things; in that case, he should not be made an imam for the Muslims.
Answer : First, it must be known that dislike is either religious, meaning they dislike him for his religion, or personal. As for personal dislike, a person must, to the best of his ability, remove it from his heart, and not harbor anything toward his Muslim brothers except love, affection, and closeness. As for religious dislike, one must look at the imam's condition. If he is in a state where his religion is not acceptable, he should not be an imam for the Muslims, such as if his conduct is bad, for example, or if he is known for engaging in more riba (usury or interest) or similar forbidden things; in that case, he should not be made an imam for the Muslims.
Source
قناة «فضيلة الشيخ محمد بن صالح العثيمين»، 59 - 60 هل تصح الصلاة خلف إمام نكرهه وهو يعلم أن المأمومين يكرهونه وهل صلاته صحيحة؟
youtube.com
youtube.com
