Why is Sayyid Qutb not declared a disbeliever for insulting the Companions and mentioning inappropriate words about the Prophet of Allah, Musa?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question:
Why is Sayyid Qutb not declared a disbeliever? Because he insulted the Companions and mentioned inappropriate words about the Prophet of Allah, Musa.
Answer:
In any case, he erred in this, and we do not know what his final state was. Perhaps he was a follower of a scholar (mقلid) who was transmitting from the books of the Shi'ah, so he was a follower of a scholar. We hold a good opinion of him and say that he erred and did not reach the level of disbelief, if Allah wills. Yes.
Why is Sayyid Qutb not declared a disbeliever? Because he insulted the Companions and mentioned inappropriate words about the Prophet of Allah, Musa.
Answer:
In any case, he erred in this, and we do not know what his final state was. Perhaps he was a follower of a scholar (mقلid) who was transmitting from the books of the Shi'ah, so he was a follower of a scholar. We hold a good opinion of him and say that he erred and did not reach the level of disbelief, if Allah wills. Yes.
Source
قناة «العلامة الدكتور صالح الفوزان»، 239 - لماذا لا يُكفّر السيد قطب لأنه سبَّ الصحابة وذكر كلاما غير لائق في نبي الله موسى؟ — youtube.com
The Arabic text is a machine transcription of the audio recording.