The jurists' definition of the poor person makes the poor person non-existent in reality, so who is the poor person?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner : Sometimes a person searches for a poor person or a needy person to give his zakah to, according to the definition the jurists gave, and he does not find anyone who fits that definition. Sometimes you do not find anyone in a specific area.
The Shaykh : No, no, I said two years. No, if Allah wills, everyone will be safe. And the reality is that the term "one year" cannot be fixed either, because if we estimate that this man is sufficient with ten thousand according to our current estimate, perhaps things will increase, or not? They increase and it is not enough, and it is worse, and perhaps things will decrease and five thousand is enough, but according to what appears to him, or it is said if a person, for example, has a salary of one thousand riyals every month and his expenses are one thousand and five hundred every month, here we know that the man is poor, because his current salary is enough for him for eight months, so he is poor. This has been said, but it is not fixed, and perhaps the poor person in this country is much richer than the poor person in another country.
The Shaykh : No, no, I said two years. No, if Allah wills, everyone will be safe. And the reality is that the term "one year" cannot be fixed either, because if we estimate that this man is sufficient with ten thousand according to our current estimate, perhaps things will increase, or not? They increase and it is not enough, and it is worse, and perhaps things will decrease and five thousand is enough, but according to what appears to him, or it is said if a person, for example, has a salary of one thousand riyals every month and his expenses are one thousand and five hundred every month, here we know that the man is poor, because his current salary is enough for him for eight months, so he is poor. This has been said, but it is not fixed, and perhaps the poor person in this country is much richer than the poor person in another country.
Source
قناة «فضيلة الشيخ محمد بن صالح العثيمين»، 1358 - 4600 في تعريف الفقهاء للفقير يجعل الفقير غير موجود في الواقع فمن هو الفقير؟ ابن عثيمين
youtube.com
youtube.com
