What is the wisdom behind reciting aloud in the night prayer and reciting quietly in the daytime prayer?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question : If someone asks: The night prayer is recited aloud and the daytime prayer is recited quietly, why is that? What is the wisdom in reciting aloud in the night prayer and quietly in the daytime prayer?
Answer : The answer is that whispers of the Shaytan are fewer at night, and the heart and tongue gather together on the recitation. Therefore, the gathering of the people on the imam's voice and the imam's recitation is more eloquent than their being scattered. For this reason, reciting aloud is not prescribed in the daytime except in a congregational prayer, such as the Friday prayer, the two festivals, the prayer for rain, and the eclipse prayer.
Because the people gather, and there is no doubt that their silence during the imam's recitation makes their recitation one single recitation, because the listener is like the reciter. But if the imam were to recite quietly, each person would recite to himself. So in this, in the reciting aloud, yes. Or rather, reciting aloud is more unifying for the recitation, because they gather on one recitation, unlike the quiet recitation. This is what appears to me to be the wisdom in reciting aloud in the Friday prayer, the two festivals, and the like, and also in the night prayer.
Answer : The answer is that whispers of the Shaytan are fewer at night, and the heart and tongue gather together on the recitation. Therefore, the gathering of the people on the imam's voice and the imam's recitation is more eloquent than their being scattered. For this reason, reciting aloud is not prescribed in the daytime except in a congregational prayer, such as the Friday prayer, the two festivals, the prayer for rain, and the eclipse prayer.
Because the people gather, and there is no doubt that their silence during the imam's recitation makes their recitation one single recitation, because the listener is like the reciter. But if the imam were to recite quietly, each person would recite to himself. So in this, in the reciting aloud, yes. Or rather, reciting aloud is more unifying for the recitation, because they gather on one recitation, unlike the quiet recitation. This is what appears to me to be the wisdom in reciting aloud in the Friday prayer, the two festivals, and the like, and also in the night prayer.
Source
قناة «فضيلة الشيخ محمد بن صالح العثيمين»، 1115ما هي الحكمة في أن يجهر في...📔 الشرح الممتع على زاد المستقنع - ابن عثيمين - مشروع كبار العلماء
youtube.com
youtube.com
