The sufficiency of the sacrificial animal for Tamattu' and Qiran in place of the 'Id sacrifice

Question:
The Honorable Shaykh, may Allah grant you success, asks: Does the sacrificial animal for Tamattu' and Qiran... Yes. Yusuf.

Answer:
If the 'Id sacrifice is obligatory, the sacrificial animal for the pilgrimage does not suffice for it. As for the 'Id sacrifice when it is a recommended practice, Ibn al-Qayyim (may Allah have mercy on him) says in *Zad al-Ma'ad* that it does suffice. What is required of him is that he slaughters on the day of the festival, and he has slaughtered on the day of the festival; he slaughtered the sacrificial animal and performed the rites. This suffices for the 'Id sacrifice, provided the 'Id sacrifice is a recommended practice. However, if the 'Id sacrifice is obligatory because he vowed it, or if it is a bequest, the sacrificial animal for the pilgrimage does not suffice for it. Yes.