What is the correct methodology in criticizing the statements of scholars and preachers in this age?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner : A questioner says: What is the correct methodology in criticizing the statements of scholars and preachers in this age? Is it by mentioning only the errors, or by mentioning both the correct and the incorrect, or does that differ depending on the circumstances of the critic?
The Shaykh : Yes, there is a distinction here. As for one who wants to evaluate a person, let him mention his good deeds and his bad deeds, unless the bad deeds outweigh the good deeds; in that case, he does not mention the good deeds, because if he did...
The questioner : ...the good deeds would mean that he has diminished the significance of the bad deeds.
The Shaykh : As for one who wants to clarify an error, let him clarify the error, even if the person has done much good. However, in this case, he does not state that so-and-so is the one who erred, because he only wants to clarify the error.
The Shaykh : Yes, there is a distinction here. As for one who wants to evaluate a person, let him mention his good deeds and his bad deeds, unless the bad deeds outweigh the good deeds; in that case, he does not mention the good deeds, because if he did...
The questioner : ...the good deeds would mean that he has diminished the significance of the bad deeds.
The Shaykh : As for one who wants to clarify an error, let him clarify the error, even if the person has done much good. However, in this case, he does not state that so-and-so is the one who erred, because he only wants to clarify the error.
Source
قناة «فضيلة الشيخ محمد بن صالح العثيمين»، 44 - 48 ما هو المنهج الحق في نقد أقوال العلماء والدعاة في هذا الزمان؟ - ابن عثيمين
youtube.com
youtube.com
