What is the ruling if a man bequeathed a specific type of oil to someone, and then it was mixed with another type?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner : Among such cases is if he bequeathed a ratal of a specific oil to him, and then it was mixed with another oil.
The Shaykh : The one with the better quality, the one with the better quality.
The questioner : Then it was mixed with another oil. If we say it is a partnership, the bequest is not invalidated. If we say it is consumption, it is invalidated.
The Shaykh : Yes, it is clear. Because if the bequeathed item is destroyed, the bequest is invalidated. So if we say it is consumption, it means it was destroyed, and the bequest is invalidated. If we say it is a partnership, it remains, so the bequest is not invalidated. And the most likely view, and Allah knows best, is that this is a partnership. The most likely view is that in all cases, it is a partnership. Because my right remains now. So this oil that was with me, a mudd, when it was mixed with a mudd, how much did it become? Two mudds. It was not actually consumed. The two mudds became shared between me and the owner of the other oil. No, no, it is not by species. If it is of a different type, such as the original oil differed, then we might say it is consumption.
The Shaykh : The one with the better quality, the one with the better quality.
The questioner : Then it was mixed with another oil. If we say it is a partnership, the bequest is not invalidated. If we say it is consumption, it is invalidated.
The Shaykh : Yes, it is clear. Because if the bequeathed item is destroyed, the bequest is invalidated. So if we say it is consumption, it means it was destroyed, and the bequest is invalidated. If we say it is a partnership, it remains, so the bequest is not invalidated. And the most likely view, and Allah knows best, is that this is a partnership. The most likely view is that in all cases, it is a partnership. Because my right remains now. So this oil that was with me, a mudd, when it was mixed with a mudd, how much did it become? Two mudds. It was not actually consumed. The two mudds became shared between me and the owner of the other oil. No, no, it is not by species. If it is of a different type, such as the original oil differed, then we might say it is consumption.
Source
قناة «فضيلة الشيخ محمد بن صالح العثيمين»، 240 - ما الحكم لو لوصى لرجل بزيت من نوع معين ثم خلطه بنوع آخر؟ قواعد ابن رجب - ابن عثيمين
youtube.com
youtube.com
