Zakah on Real Estate
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question : The questioner says: I have five shops in Riyadh, and a lunar year has passed over them, but they have not been rented out yet. Is zakah obligatory on them or not?
Answer : This is a matter on which we have spoken extensively and clearly. Now we say that it should be known that all real estate prepared for exploitation through renting does not have zakah on it, as long as the owner has prepared these properties for himself to exploit them for rent. He does not owe zakah on these properties themselves; rather, the zakah is on their rent. The zakah is on the rent. This is exactly like the land that a person farms; he does not owe zakah on the land, but the zakah is on the fruit or crops he takes from it, as the Sunnah has stated.
As for the claim of some people that if a person has properties he rents out, they are in the position of trade goods, that is a false statement. The difference between them and trade goods is that the owner of trade goods does not want the item itself; he does not want the property itself, but rather wants to sell and buy it and earn a living through buying and selling, not through exploiting it. There is a difference between the two. But what is the zakah on the rent?
The zakah on the rent is one-quarter of one-tenth. That is, if the properties were worth millions of millions and he is renting them out, there is no zakah on the properties themselves, but what is the zakah on the rent? The zakah on the rent is one-quarter of one-tenth, meaning one out of forty, because the rent is in dirhams, and the zakah on dirhams is one-quarter of one-tenth. As for those who claim that the zakah on the rent is half of one-tenth by analogy with the zakah on crops, that is a false analogy, because it contradicts the explicit text. Allah, through the tongue of His Messenger (peace and blessings be upon him), did not obligate anything other than one-quarter of one-tenth on gold, silver, and what is made a substitute for them. Half of one-tenth is only for crops and fruits, not for money or what serves as its equivalent.
The conclusion is that this analogy, which contradicts the explicit text, and any other analogy that contradicts the text, requires that the face of its proponent be struck so that he may turn back on his heels and not proceed with an analogy for which Allah has not sent down any authority.
Answer : This is a matter on which we have spoken extensively and clearly. Now we say that it should be known that all real estate prepared for exploitation through renting does not have zakah on it, as long as the owner has prepared these properties for himself to exploit them for rent. He does not owe zakah on these properties themselves; rather, the zakah is on their rent. The zakah is on the rent. This is exactly like the land that a person farms; he does not owe zakah on the land, but the zakah is on the fruit or crops he takes from it, as the Sunnah has stated.
As for the claim of some people that if a person has properties he rents out, they are in the position of trade goods, that is a false statement. The difference between them and trade goods is that the owner of trade goods does not want the item itself; he does not want the property itself, but rather wants to sell and buy it and earn a living through buying and selling, not through exploiting it. There is a difference between the two. But what is the zakah on the rent?
The zakah on the rent is one-quarter of one-tenth. That is, if the properties were worth millions of millions and he is renting them out, there is no zakah on the properties themselves, but what is the zakah on the rent? The zakah on the rent is one-quarter of one-tenth, meaning one out of forty, because the rent is in dirhams, and the zakah on dirhams is one-quarter of one-tenth. As for those who claim that the zakah on the rent is half of one-tenth by analogy with the zakah on crops, that is a false analogy, because it contradicts the explicit text. Allah, through the tongue of His Messenger (peace and blessings be upon him), did not obligate anything other than one-quarter of one-tenth on gold, silver, and what is made a substitute for them. Half of one-tenth is only for crops and fruits, not for money or what serves as its equivalent.
The conclusion is that this analogy, which contradicts the explicit text, and any other analogy that contradicts the text, requires that the face of its proponent be struck so that he may turn back on his heels and not proceed with an analogy for which Allah has not sent down any authority.
Source
قناة «فضيلة الشيخ محمد بن صالح العثيمين»، لقاء[31 من 83] زكاة العقارات - الشيخ ابن عثيمين - مشروع كبار العلماء
youtube.com
youtube.com
