Does phlegm break the fast?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question : The questioner says: Does swallowing phlegm break the fast? If it does, I have done so without intending to, as I heard a hadith that it breaks the fast, but I am not certain. Do I have to make up the fast for having done that?
Answer : Yes, phlegm or mucus. If it does not reach the mouth, it does not break the fast, according to the unanimous opinion in the school of thought. If it reaches the mouth and then you swallow it, there are two opinions among the scholars. Some said it breaks the fast, by analogy to eating and drinking. Others said it does not break the fast, by analogy to saliva.
For saliva does not invalidate the fast, even if one collects his saliva and swallows it, his fast is not invalidated. The scholars differ on this. If the scholars differ, what is the reference? The reference is the Book and the Sunnah. If we are in doubt about this matter—whether it invalidates the act of worship or not—what is the default? The default is that it does not invalidate. Based on this, swallowing mucus does not break the fast.
But the difficult thing is that some people, in order to exaggerate and be excessive in fasting, when they feel mucus in their throat, they try to get it out. You find them coughing and clearing their throats and straining to expel it, fearing that it will go from there to the stomach. This is undoubtedly a form of excessive strictness (tanattu'). Some people even asked me, saying that he did this until he vomited. So now, how does Satan play with the children of Adam? He leads them to ruin their fast, because if a person intentionally vomits, his fast is invalidated. So the important thing is to leave the mucus alone and not try to expel it. But if it comes out to the mouth, expel it, whether you are fasting or not. As for breaking the fast, it requires evidence that serves as a proof for the person before Allah the Mighty and Majestic in invalidating the fast.
Answer : Yes, phlegm or mucus. If it does not reach the mouth, it does not break the fast, according to the unanimous opinion in the school of thought. If it reaches the mouth and then you swallow it, there are two opinions among the scholars. Some said it breaks the fast, by analogy to eating and drinking. Others said it does not break the fast, by analogy to saliva.
For saliva does not invalidate the fast, even if one collects his saliva and swallows it, his fast is not invalidated. The scholars differ on this. If the scholars differ, what is the reference? The reference is the Book and the Sunnah. If we are in doubt about this matter—whether it invalidates the act of worship or not—what is the default? The default is that it does not invalidate. Based on this, swallowing mucus does not break the fast.
But the difficult thing is that some people, in order to exaggerate and be excessive in fasting, when they feel mucus in their throat, they try to get it out. You find them coughing and clearing their throats and straining to expel it, fearing that it will go from there to the stomach. This is undoubtedly a form of excessive strictness (tanattu'). Some people even asked me, saying that he did this until he vomited. So now, how does Satan play with the children of Adam? He leads them to ruin their fast, because if a person intentionally vomits, his fast is invalidated. So the important thing is to leave the mucus alone and not try to expel it. But if it comes out to the mouth, expel it, whether you are fasting or not. As for breaking the fast, it requires evidence that serves as a proof for the person before Allah the Mighty and Majestic in invalidating the fast.
Source
قناة «فضيلة الشيخ محمد بن صالح العثيمين»، لقاء[42 من 93] هل البلغم يفطر الصائم؟!! الشيخ ابن عثيمين - مشروع كبار العلماء
youtube.com
youtube.com
