The ruling on the claim of non-intercourse on the wedding night
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner : We have presented evidence from those who cited the action of Abu Bakr and 'Umar (may Allah be pleased with them both), who were abstinent despite their ability to do otherwise, fearing that people would assume it was an obligation. It is an obligation, and now we are discussing the constraints of the texts and the disagreement among the Companions on this matter. We followed the statement of 'Ali and 'Umar, in opposition to Ibn Mas'ud, who was one of the jurists of the Companions.
The Shaykh : We do not assert with certainty, but we fear this.
The questioner : But Shaykh.
The Shaykh : Because in this evidence, the reason is that they feared people would assume it was an obligation due to their opinion, whereas the hadiths are clear, clear in the obligation. As for this, it does not reach that level of clarity, because as Ibn Hajar said, the presumption takes the place of the confirmed, meaning the confirmed matter, because a person, in most cases, when he is alone with his wife on the wedding night, usually does not hold back. For example, a person might say that he did not have intercourse, perhaps saying so to avoid losing his right. Therefore, Malik distinguished, saying that if it is in his house, it has one ruling, and if it is in her house, it has another ruling. His statement is accepted in her house, and his statement is accepted in his house, meaning. Yes, and if he persists, a person who does not fear Allah might give the menstruating woman [intercourse] and not care. Yes, if they agree that no intercourse took place, this is the issue. Where does that mean? She has the waiting period, she has the waiting period.
The Shaykh : We do not assert with certainty, but we fear this.
The questioner : But Shaykh.
The Shaykh : Because in this evidence, the reason is that they feared people would assume it was an obligation due to their opinion, whereas the hadiths are clear, clear in the obligation. As for this, it does not reach that level of clarity, because as Ibn Hajar said, the presumption takes the place of the confirmed, meaning the confirmed matter, because a person, in most cases, when he is alone with his wife on the wedding night, usually does not hold back. For example, a person might say that he did not have intercourse, perhaps saying so to avoid losing his right. Therefore, Malik distinguished, saying that if it is in his house, it has one ruling, and if it is in her house, it has another ruling. His statement is accepted in her house, and his statement is accepted in his house, meaning. Yes, and if he persists, a person who does not fear Allah might give the menstruating woman [intercourse] and not care. Yes, if they agree that no intercourse took place, this is the issue. Where does that mean? She has the waiting period, she has the waiting period.
Source
قناة «فضيلة الشيخ محمد بن صالح العثيمين»، 2233 - 4600 هل نأخذ بقول علي وعمر في وجوب المهر كله لمن سمي لها مهراً وخلا بها ولم...؟ ابن عثيمين
youtube.com
youtube.com
