The Number of Tashahhuds in the Maghrib Prayer and the Passing of a Car
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner : Is it possible for there to be six tashahhuds in a single prayer?
The Shaykh : Yes. Is it possible for a person’s prayer to be invalidated by a car passing by? And things like that. As you know, people like the unusual; if you bring them something like this, they turn to you completely. The second issue is six tashahhuds in a single prayer, specifically the Maghrib prayer. If a latecomer catches one rak’ah and joins the imam after he has bowed in the second rak’ah, yes, then there is the imam’s first tashahhud, which does not count for him, and the imam’s second tashahhud. The imam made a mistake in the place of his prostration after the salam, according to the view that he follows the imam in this, so he followed his imam and performed the prostration for forgetfulness with his imam. Then he said the salam with his imam while forgetting; he said the salam while forgetting. Then he stood up to make up the missed part, but he sat down in the first rak’ah for the first tashahhud. This makes four, yes. Then he sat down for the final tashahhud, the fifth. Then he prostrated for forgetfulness after the salam because he said the salam before completing the prayer. This is the sixth. This scenario is not possible except in the Maghrib prayer, meaning it is not possible in the Zuhr, Asr, or Isha prayers. The third issue is the passing of a car. This is a person who has performed tayammum, and they sent someone to bring them water. He entered the prayer thinking he had performed tayammum, and then a car passed by with a jug of water in it. His tayammum is invalidated, and then his prayer is invalidated. The matter became a dispute between us, O Abd al-Rahman. Are you from Bahrain? Give us your questions.
The Shaykh : Yes. Is it possible for a person’s prayer to be invalidated by a car passing by? And things like that. As you know, people like the unusual; if you bring them something like this, they turn to you completely. The second issue is six tashahhuds in a single prayer, specifically the Maghrib prayer. If a latecomer catches one rak’ah and joins the imam after he has bowed in the second rak’ah, yes, then there is the imam’s first tashahhud, which does not count for him, and the imam’s second tashahhud. The imam made a mistake in the place of his prostration after the salam, according to the view that he follows the imam in this, so he followed his imam and performed the prostration for forgetfulness with his imam. Then he said the salam with his imam while forgetting; he said the salam while forgetting. Then he stood up to make up the missed part, but he sat down in the first rak’ah for the first tashahhud. This makes four, yes. Then he sat down for the final tashahhud, the fifth. Then he prostrated for forgetfulness after the salam because he said the salam before completing the prayer. This is the sixth. This scenario is not possible except in the Maghrib prayer, meaning it is not possible in the Zuhr, Asr, or Isha prayers. The third issue is the passing of a car. This is a person who has performed tayammum, and they sent someone to bring them water. He entered the prayer thinking he had performed tayammum, and then a car passed by with a jug of water in it. His tayammum is invalidated, and then his prayer is invalidated. The matter became a dispute between us, O Abd al-Rahman. Are you from Bahrain? Give us your questions.
Source
قناة «فضيلة الشيخ محمد بن صالح العثيمين»، 166 - 178 من غرائب المسائل هل يمكن أن يكون في صلاة واحدة ست تشهدات؟ وهل ممكن تبطل صلاة الشخص...
youtube.com
youtube.com
