If one descends into the Haram and wants to spread a carpet on the ground but fears breaking the trees, is that permissible?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner : Well, if he places a carpet on the ground, and there is grass there. Generally, this grass will die or be broken. So do we say it is not permissible to spread the carpet because this breaks the grass or damages it, or is it permissible to spread the carpet? It is permissible, but without intention. Well, he has now descended, for example, you know the ground varies; one side may have lighter grass than the other, right? Do we say you are required to descend on the lighter side? Or does it not matter, and this and that will not die from it.
The Shaykh : Yes. I hope you all, my brothers, now, he has descended on land where one side has light vegetation and the other side has a lot of vegetation, and a lot, I mean here, I mean it does not matter to him, it does not matter to him, he said, did he descend here or here? So do we say you descend on the lighter side? Or does he have a choice? He has a choice, yes, descend on the lighter side, no, descend on the lighter side, because killing one is easier than killing ten or two, so destroying one tree is easier than destroying several trees. But if the light area is far from his destination, we say you are in Mina, for example, or in Muzdalifah, or in a light place, we do not say that. But if you now have this tent next to it or with little vegetation, and you staked it in a place with a lot of vegetation, we say no, to prevent harm, because the more specific it is, the more it is humility.
The Shaykh : Yes. I hope you all, my brothers, now, he has descended on land where one side has light vegetation and the other side has a lot of vegetation, and a lot, I mean here, I mean it does not matter to him, it does not matter to him, he said, did he descend here or here? So do we say you descend on the lighter side? Or does he have a choice? He has a choice, yes, descend on the lighter side, no, descend on the lighter side, because killing one is easier than killing ten or two, so destroying one tree is easier than destroying several trees. But if the light area is far from his destination, we say you are in Mina, for example, or in Muzdalifah, or in a light place, we do not say that. But if you now have this tent next to it or with little vegetation, and you staked it in a place with a lot of vegetation, we say no, to prevent harm, because the more specific it is, the more it is humility.
Source
قناة «فضيلة الشيخ محمد بن صالح العثيمين»، 560- إذا نزل في الحرم وأراد فرش بساط على الأرض فخاف من كسر شجر، فهل يجوز؟ II ابن عثيمين
youtube.com
youtube.com
