What is the evidence for the author's view that shortening the prayer is a recommended practice?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner : What is the author's evidence? What is the evidence for the author's view that it is a recommended practice and not obligatory?
The Shaykh : Yes, that you should shorten the prayer. Fine. This may be answered from various angles. Fine, it is answered to us by 'Umrah, the sa'y between al-Safa and al-Marwah, Hajj and 'Umrah. Allah said:[Al-Baqarah 2:158]
The questioner : Because it is not a review.
The Shaykh : The omission. Yes, fine. As for charity, some of it is obligatory. "Indeed, alms are for the poor." How is the original that it was four in the beginning when you finished two rak'ahs, then it was increased? Charity, and when the Messenger said "Accept your charity," we were commanded to accept it, and the original ruling of a command is obligation. So, fine.
The questioner : I mean, is the evidence like the consensus of the Companions regarding completing the prayer behind 'Umar, despite their disapproval of him? Is that so?
The Shaykh : Fine, if someone were to say that the obligation of shortening the prayer is opposed by the obligation of following the imam. So the shortening is dropped, just as the first tashahhud is dropped if the imam forgets it and stands up.
The questioner : Khalid, the issue is actually good, it is not easy. The view of obligation is very strong, it is not easy.
The Shaykh : Yes, Khalid.
The questioner : I mean, if we say that shortening the prayer is obligatory, does that necessitate the invalidity of the prayer by completing it? Is that so? And following the imam.
The Shaykh : In what invalidates the prayer. It is not permissible. For this reason, if the imam prays six, it is not permissible to pray six. This is the least that can be said in refuting the view of obligation: that it can be said that the Companions were almost in consensus on completing the prayer behind 'Umar (may Allah be pleased with him). And if shortening had been obligatory, they would not have completed it behind him. And it has also been argued with what the brother said: "Charity, may Allah bestow it upon you." But this is answered by the fact that charity may be obligatory, due to His saying:[At-Tawbah 9:60]. Also, the establishment of the obligation of this charity is that the Messenger said "So accept the charity." And the majority did not make it obligatory in all cases. The least of the states of completing the prayer is that it is disliked.
The Shaykh : Yes, that you should shorten the prayer. Fine. This may be answered from various angles. Fine, it is answered to us by 'Umrah, the sa'y between al-Safa and al-Marwah, Hajj and 'Umrah. Allah said:
there is no blame upon him for walking between them
فَلَا جُنَاحَ عَلَيْهِ أَن يَطَّوَّفَ بِهِمَاThe questioner : Because it is not a review.
The Shaykh : The omission. Yes, fine. As for charity, some of it is obligatory. "Indeed, alms are for the poor." How is the original that it was four in the beginning when you finished two rak'ahs, then it was increased? Charity, and when the Messenger said "Accept your charity," we were commanded to accept it, and the original ruling of a command is obligation. So, fine.
The questioner : I mean, is the evidence like the consensus of the Companions regarding completing the prayer behind 'Umar, despite their disapproval of him? Is that so?
The Shaykh : Fine, if someone were to say that the obligation of shortening the prayer is opposed by the obligation of following the imam. So the shortening is dropped, just as the first tashahhud is dropped if the imam forgets it and stands up.
The questioner : Khalid, the issue is actually good, it is not easy. The view of obligation is very strong, it is not easy.
The Shaykh : Yes, Khalid.
The questioner : I mean, if we say that shortening the prayer is obligatory, does that necessitate the invalidity of the prayer by completing it? Is that so? And following the imam.
The Shaykh : In what invalidates the prayer. It is not permissible. For this reason, if the imam prays six, it is not permissible to pray six. This is the least that can be said in refuting the view of obligation: that it can be said that the Companions were almost in consensus on completing the prayer behind 'Umar (may Allah be pleased with him). And if shortening had been obligatory, they would not have completed it behind him. And it has also been argued with what the brother said: "Charity, may Allah bestow it upon you." But this is answered by the fact that charity may be obligatory, due to His saying:
Zakah expenditures are only for the poor
إِنَّمَا الصَّدَقَاتُ لِلْفُقَرَاءِ
Source
قناة «فضيلة الشيخ محمد بن صالح العثيمين»، 4124ما الدليل لرأيِ المؤلف أن القصر سُنَّة؟📔 الشرح الممتع على زاد المستقنع - ابن عثيمين
youtube.com
youtube.com
