The Difference Between One Who Rents Out a Shop in Which a Forbidden Item Is Sold and One Who Rents Out a House for Residence in Which a Forbidden Act Is Committed
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The Shaykh : Yes, that is how it is.
The questioner : I ask Allah: What is the difference between renting out a shop in which a person commits a forbidden act, and renting out a place for a forbidden act, and selling a forbidden item, versus one who rents out a house for residence in which a right is committed? A great difference. We said in the first case, regarding prayer, if one prays suddenly...
The Shaykh : The difference between them is: a person rents a house from another to make it a church. This is forbidden. Because the benefit for which the house was rented is a forbidden benefit. He rented this house to reside in it, but he committed a forbidden act in it. So the original state, the original contract, is lawful.
The questioner : Renting it out for the sale of lawful items, but a right is committed in it.
The Shaykh : Hmm?
The questioner : So he sold a forbidden item, for he rented it as a shop and sold in the shop.
The Shaykh : All right, here is the correct answer. Yes. Who is the one who stipulates? He stipulates on what?
The questioner : He rents out the good.
The Shaykh : Yes, yes. And even if he did not stipulate, but if we know, by the established custom, that the owners of grocery stores must have cigarettes, then what does this invalidate?
The questioner : I ask Allah: What is the difference between renting out a shop in which a person commits a forbidden act, and renting out a place for a forbidden act, and selling a forbidden item, versus one who rents out a house for residence in which a right is committed? A great difference. We said in the first case, regarding prayer, if one prays suddenly...
The Shaykh : The difference between them is: a person rents a house from another to make it a church. This is forbidden. Because the benefit for which the house was rented is a forbidden benefit. He rented this house to reside in it, but he committed a forbidden act in it. So the original state, the original contract, is lawful.
The questioner : Renting it out for the sale of lawful items, but a right is committed in it.
The Shaykh : Hmm?
The questioner : So he sold a forbidden item, for he rented it as a shop and sold in the shop.
The Shaykh : All right, here is the correct answer. Yes. Who is the one who stipulates? He stipulates on what?
The questioner : He rents out the good.
The Shaykh : Yes, yes. And even if he did not stipulate, but if we know, by the established custom, that the owners of grocery stores must have cigarettes, then what does this invalidate?
Source
قناة «فضيلة الشيخ محمد بن صالح العثيمين»، [5029] وجه الفرق بين من أجر محله وباع فيه محرمًا ومن أجر بيته للسكن وعمل فيه محرمًا
youtube.com
youtube.com
