The ruling on following dispensations among the scholars' statements
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question : The questioner says: Some people seek out dispensations (rukhsah). That is, if a scholar gives them a ruling that does not suit them, they go to another scholar to get a ruling that does suit them. It is well known that this is not permissible. Rather, if a person consults a scholar he trusts, believing that his words are the Shari'ah,
Answer : and he did not consult him except while holding that belief, then he should not consult anyone else. The scholars have explicitly stated this, saying that if a man consults a scholar and is committed to what he says, it is forbidden (haram) for him to consult anyone else. Yes, if you consulted a scholar and he gave you a ruling, and you committed to his words, and then you attended a scholarly gathering and heard a scholar stating the opposite of the ruling you were given, supporting his statement with evidence, then there is no blame on you for moving from the first scholar's ruling to what the second scholar said. Likewise, suppose you are in a country where there are scholars, but you consulted the scholar in your country with the intention that if you find another scholar, you will do so; then there is no blame in asking this scholar in your country. And if you arrive in another country where there is a scholar you see as more knowledgeable than the one who gave you the ruling, then consult him. At that point, we say: Do not make your religion a plaything by following what suits your desires rather than what guidance requires. And Allah the Exalted says[An-Nahl 16:43] Why do we ask them so that we may return to their words? If you consult a scholar from among the scholars and you see that his words are the truth, then you do not consult anyone else, as we mentioned at the beginning. But, by Allah, some people, when this scholar gives them a ruling, say, "Let's go, I will swear, because getting a dispensation is easier." If he leaves his mother and does not find what he wants, he says, "I will go to the second country." If it is not available in the Kingdom, he says, "I will go to another country." This is a mistake.
Answer : and he did not consult him except while holding that belief, then he should not consult anyone else. The scholars have explicitly stated this, saying that if a man consults a scholar and is committed to what he says, it is forbidden (haram) for him to consult anyone else. Yes, if you consulted a scholar and he gave you a ruling, and you committed to his words, and then you attended a scholarly gathering and heard a scholar stating the opposite of the ruling you were given, supporting his statement with evidence, then there is no blame on you for moving from the first scholar's ruling to what the second scholar said. Likewise, suppose you are in a country where there are scholars, but you consulted the scholar in your country with the intention that if you find another scholar, you will do so; then there is no blame in asking this scholar in your country. And if you arrive in another country where there is a scholar you see as more knowledgeable than the one who gave you the ruling, then consult him. At that point, we say: Do not make your religion a plaything by following what suits your desires rather than what guidance requires. And Allah the Exalted says
So ask the people of the message if you do not know.
فَاسْأَلُوا أَهْلَ الذِّكْرِ إِن كُنتُمْ لَا تَعْلَمُونَ
Source
قناة «فضيلة الشيخ محمد بن صالح العثيمين»، 62 - 79 حكم تتبع الرخص بين أقوال العلماء - الإنصاف في آداب الاختلاف - ابن عثيمين
youtube.com
youtube.com
