The ruling on a follower (ma'mum) following his imam when there is a difference in independent legal reasoning (ijtihad) regarding the direction of prayer (qiblah)
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner : Two men differed in their independent legal reasoning. Does one of them follow the other? Sami.
The Shaykh : There is a distinction here. If they differ in the direction, one does not follow the other. If they do not differ in the direction, then one follows the other, as
The questioner : I mean, if they differ in the direction. Big.
The Shaykh : One of them, the other.
The questioner : No, he did not push. For example, one says the qiblah is from the north, and this one says from the north.
The Shaykh : If they differ in the direction, and if they differ in a direction
The questioner : And if they differ in a direction, one of them follows the other.
The Shaykh : In. Did you understand?
The questioner : May Allah keep you safe.
The Shaykh : If they differ in the direction, one does not follow the other. If they differ in a direction, one follows the other. This phrase needs to be translated. What is the difference between the two phrases?
The questioner : If they differ in the direction, meaning, did this one differ in the eastern direction or the western one?
The Shaykh : One says the qiblah is west, and the other says east. Okay.
The questioner : Differing in a direction means one direction, for example, in the west direction. One said to the right, and this one said to the left. So this involves a direction. Correct.
The Shaykh : So, if they agree that the qiblah is west, but one leans to the right and the other leans to the left, then one follows the other. That is, he prays with him as a follower and also follows him in his direction. There is no harm in him leaving his independent legal reasoning and following the other, because deviation within the same direction is permissible. Okay.
The Shaykh : There is a distinction here. If they differ in the direction, one does not follow the other. If they do not differ in the direction, then one follows the other, as
The questioner : I mean, if they differ in the direction. Big.
The Shaykh : One of them, the other.
The questioner : No, he did not push. For example, one says the qiblah is from the north, and this one says from the north.
The Shaykh : If they differ in the direction, and if they differ in a direction
The questioner : And if they differ in a direction, one of them follows the other.
The Shaykh : In. Did you understand?
The questioner : May Allah keep you safe.
The Shaykh : If they differ in the direction, one does not follow the other. If they differ in a direction, one follows the other. This phrase needs to be translated. What is the difference between the two phrases?
The questioner : If they differ in the direction, meaning, did this one differ in the eastern direction or the western one?
The Shaykh : One says the qiblah is west, and the other says east. Okay.
The questioner : Differing in a direction means one direction, for example, in the west direction. One said to the right, and this one said to the left. So this involves a direction. Correct.
The Shaykh : So, if they agree that the qiblah is west, but one leans to the right and the other leans to the left, then one follows the other. That is, he prays with him as a follower and also follows him in his direction. There is no harm in him leaving his independent legal reasoning and following the other, because deviation within the same direction is permissible. Okay.
Source
قناة «فضيلة الشيخ محمد بن صالح العثيمين»، 900 اختلف اجتهاد رجلين فهل يتبع...📔 الشرح الممتع على زاد المستقنع - ابن عثيمين - مشروع كبار العلماء
youtube.com
youtube.com
