The Ruling on Renewing a Question and Reverting When the Mufti’s Ijtihad Changes
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner : The sixth point: If a person seeks a ruling, receives an answer, and then the same situation occurs for him again, is he required to ask again? There are two views on this. The first is that he is required to ask, on the grounds that the mufti’s opinion might have changed. The second is that he is not required to ask, and this is the more correct view, because he has already learned the ruling, and the default is that the mufti remains on that ruling. The author of al-Shamil specified the disagreement as applying when one follows a living scholar, and stated that if it is a report from a deceased scholar, one is not required to ask. The correct view is that it is not limited to this case, because a mufti following a deceased scholar’s school of jurisprudence might change his answer according to that school.
The Shaykh : He is not required to plan out the question. For example, if he asks about the ruling on a specific issue, such as an issue of Hajj, and is given a ruling, and then he performs Hajj in a coming year, he relies on the first ruling and is not required to ask again. Even if we said he is required to ask, we would also have to say he is required to ask another scholar, in case the other scholar disagrees with the first scholar’s independent legal reasoning. Yes.
The questioner : The seventh point: He should seek a ruling himself, and he may send someone to do so.
The Shaykh : If the scholar who gave him the ruling changed his independent legal reasoning, and the questioner did not ask him, but the scholar was asked in the questioner’s presence and gave a ruling contrary to his previous one, is the questioner required to revert because the scholar reverted, or not? The correct view is that he is not required to, unless the scholar based his reversion on evidence from the Qur’an and the Sunnah; in that case, he reverts to the Qur’an and the Sunnah. Did you understand this? That is, the scholar ruled that he must do such and such. This situation occurred for the questioner in the coming year. Is he required to ask the scholar?
He is not required to. All right, but suppose this scholar was asked about this specific issue and the mufti gave a ruling contrary to the first one. Is the first questioner required to revert as the mufti did, or not? We say he is not required to. He is not required to, unless the mufti mentioned evidence in his last ruling on which he based his disagreement with his first statement. In that case, it is obligatory for the first questioner to revert for the sake of the evidence.
The Shaykh : He is not required to plan out the question. For example, if he asks about the ruling on a specific issue, such as an issue of Hajj, and is given a ruling, and then he performs Hajj in a coming year, he relies on the first ruling and is not required to ask again. Even if we said he is required to ask, we would also have to say he is required to ask another scholar, in case the other scholar disagrees with the first scholar’s independent legal reasoning. Yes.
The questioner : The seventh point: He should seek a ruling himself, and he may send someone to do so.
The Shaykh : If the scholar who gave him the ruling changed his independent legal reasoning, and the questioner did not ask him, but the scholar was asked in the questioner’s presence and gave a ruling contrary to his previous one, is the questioner required to revert because the scholar reverted, or not? The correct view is that he is not required to, unless the scholar based his reversion on evidence from the Qur’an and the Sunnah; in that case, he reverts to the Qur’an and the Sunnah. Did you understand this? That is, the scholar ruled that he must do such and such. This situation occurred for the questioner in the coming year. Is he required to ask the scholar?
He is not required to. All right, but suppose this scholar was asked about this specific issue and the mufti gave a ruling contrary to the first one. Is the first questioner required to revert as the mufti did, or not? We say he is not required to. He is not required to, unless the mufti mentioned evidence in his last ruling on which he based his disagreement with his first statement. In that case, it is obligatory for the first questioner to revert for the sake of the evidence.
Source
قناة «فضيلة الشيخ محمد بن صالح العثيمين»، 130 -171 المسالة السادسة إذا استفتى فأفتي ثم حدثت تلك الواقعة له مرة أخرى فهل يلزمه تجديد السؤال...
youtube.com
youtube.com
