The Ruling When a Borrowed Item Is Lost
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question : Yes. Abu Abd al-Rahman. What? They agreed. Yes.
Answer : The school of thought, may Allah bless you, holds that the borrower is liable in all cases regarding the borrowed item, whether he was negligent or not. The correct view is that the borrowed item is like other trusts: if he transgressed or was negligent, he is liable; otherwise, he is not liable. It is known that if they differ on whether the matter was negligence or not, but they agree on the act itself—agreeing on what happened—yet the one in possession claims it was not negligence and the owner claims it was negligence, we refer to custom. The important point is that you mentioned a loan, but he did not mention a loan? The one in front of you is a loan, and you made a mistake. We ask Allah for certainty.
Answer : The school of thought, may Allah bless you, holds that the borrower is liable in all cases regarding the borrowed item, whether he was negligent or not. The correct view is that the borrowed item is like other trusts: if he transgressed or was negligent, he is liable; otherwise, he is not liable. It is known that if they differ on whether the matter was negligence or not, but they agree on the act itself—agreeing on what happened—yet the one in possession claims it was not negligence and the owner claims it was negligence, we refer to custom. The important point is that you mentioned a loan, but he did not mention a loan? The one in front of you is a loan, and you made a mistake. We ask Allah for certainty.
Source
قناة «فضيلة الشيخ محمد بن صالح العثيمين»، 4525 - الحكم عند هلاك العارية - تعليقات على الكافي لابن عثيمين
youtube.com
youtube.com
