On the remembrance of Allah with the heart and the tongue
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question : The questioner asks: Is the remembrance of the tongue better, or the remembrance of the heart, or both?
Answer : We say that there is no doubt that if the heart and the tongue are combined, that is the best of the ranks. Then the remembrance of the heart follows. However, sometimes the remembrance of the tongue is required alongside the remembrance of the heart. For example, if someone says, "When I bow, I remember in my heart that Allah is the Magnificent, but I do not say it with my tongue," that is not sufficient for him. Sometimes the remembrance of the tongue is necessary, even if the heart does not remember. And sometimes the remembrance of the heart is better. There is no doubt that the remembrance of the heart brings more impact on the heart and soundness of intention than the mere remembrance of the tongue. But some dhikr (remembrance) must be said with the tongue. Therefore, the answer to this issue is not fixed, because it varies.
Answer : We say that there is no doubt that if the heart and the tongue are combined, that is the best of the ranks. Then the remembrance of the heart follows. However, sometimes the remembrance of the tongue is required alongside the remembrance of the heart. For example, if someone says, "When I bow, I remember in my heart that Allah is the Magnificent, but I do not say it with my tongue," that is not sufficient for him. Sometimes the remembrance of the tongue is necessary, even if the heart does not remember. And sometimes the remembrance of the heart is better. There is no doubt that the remembrance of the heart brings more impact on the heart and soundness of intention than the mere remembrance of the tongue. But some dhikr (remembrance) must be said with the tongue. Therefore, the answer to this issue is not fixed, because it varies.
Source
قناة «فضيلة الشيخ محمد بن صالح العثيمين»، لقاء[18 من 46] عن ذكر الله بالقلب واللسان - الشيخ ابن عثيمين - مشروع كبار العلماء
youtube.com
youtube.com
