Is the 'Id sacrifice permissible in Makkah?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question : If an 'aqiqah and an 'Id sacrifice coincide, does the 'Id sacrifice suffice for the 'aqiqah, or not? There are two narrated positions on this. The same applies if a hady and an 'Id sacrifice coincide. Shaykh Taqiy al-Din chose the position that there is no 'Id sacrifice in Makkah; rather, it is hady. Among these,
Answer : and what the Shaykh (may Allah have mercy on him) mentioned is strong, but only for the people of Makkah, for the people of Makkah offer the 'Id sacrifice just like others. As for those from outside Makkah, what they slaughter is considered hady, not an 'Id sacrifice. Based on the Shaykh's (may Allah have mercy on him) choice, we say that it is possible for hady and an 'Id sacrifice to coincide in the case of a non-Makkan, and the ruling in his case is that it is hady.
Answer : and what the Shaykh (may Allah have mercy on him) mentioned is strong, but only for the people of Makkah, for the people of Makkah offer the 'Id sacrifice just like others. As for those from outside Makkah, what they slaughter is considered hady, not an 'Id sacrifice. Based on the Shaykh's (may Allah have mercy on him) choice, we say that it is possible for hady and an 'Id sacrifice to coincide in the case of a non-Makkan, and the ruling in his case is that it is hady.
Source
قناة «فضيلة الشيخ محمد بن صالح العثيمين»، 207 - هل تجوز الأضحية في مكة؟ قواعد ابن رجب - ابن عثيمين
youtube.com
youtube.com
