Is it better for the one in i'tikaf (spiritual retreat in the mosque) to limit himself to reciting the Qur'an, dhikr (the remembrance of Allah), and worship, or should he teach knowledge, engage in debate, and review?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner : Now, is it better for the one in i'tikaf to limit himself to reciting the Qur'an, dhikr, and worship, or to teach knowledge, engage in debate, and review? The second hour.
The Shaykh : There are two opinions on this. But if the matter comes down to whether one should perform i'tikaf—if we say that it is better to recite the Qur'an and not engage in debate, teaching, or learning—then is it better to abandon i'tikaf for these things, or to do these things and abandon i'tikaf? In other words, is it better to perform i'tikaf and leave these things, or to do these things and leave i'tikaf? The second option is undoubtedly better, because teaching knowledge is better than i'tikaf. This is unless one intends to revive a sunnah (recommended practice), such as in a town where the people do not know i'tikaf and do not trust one another. If he performs i'tikaf—meaning, if an ordinary person performs i'tikaf—the people will not follow his example and will not take him as a model. But if this is a student of knowledge who wants to revive this sunnah, we tell him: It is better for you to perform i'tikaf. This is because people follow actions more strongly than they follow words. Otherwise, the student of knowledge could simply tell the people, "Perform i'tikaf, for i'tikaf is a sunnah," but people follow actions more than they follow words.
The conclusion is that if the matter comes down to whether the one in i'tikaf should occupy himself exclusively with reciting the Qur'an, dhikr, and acts of worship, and be occupied away from knowledge, teaching, debate, and review, or whether he should occupy himself with the latter and not the former, then occupying himself with the latter and not the former is better. This is unless there is a specific reason that necessitates the former.
The Shaykh : There are two opinions on this. But if the matter comes down to whether one should perform i'tikaf—if we say that it is better to recite the Qur'an and not engage in debate, teaching, or learning—then is it better to abandon i'tikaf for these things, or to do these things and abandon i'tikaf? In other words, is it better to perform i'tikaf and leave these things, or to do these things and leave i'tikaf? The second option is undoubtedly better, because teaching knowledge is better than i'tikaf. This is unless one intends to revive a sunnah (recommended practice), such as in a town where the people do not know i'tikaf and do not trust one another. If he performs i'tikaf—meaning, if an ordinary person performs i'tikaf—the people will not follow his example and will not take him as a model. But if this is a student of knowledge who wants to revive this sunnah, we tell him: It is better for you to perform i'tikaf. This is because people follow actions more strongly than they follow words. Otherwise, the student of knowledge could simply tell the people, "Perform i'tikaf, for i'tikaf is a sunnah," but people follow actions more than they follow words.
The conclusion is that if the matter comes down to whether the one in i'tikaf should occupy himself exclusively with reciting the Qur'an, dhikr, and acts of worship, and be occupied away from knowledge, teaching, debate, and review, or whether he should occupy himself with the latter and not the former, then occupying himself with the latter and not the former is better. This is unless there is a specific reason that necessitates the former.
Source
قناة «فضيلة الشيخ محمد بن صالح العثيمين»، 2379 - هل المعتكف الأفضل أن يقتصر على قراءة القرآن والذكر والعبادة أو أن يعلم العلم ويناظر ويذاكر؟
youtube.com
youtube.com
