Text copied Link copied

Al-Fatawa – home

﴿ فَاسْأَلُوا أَهْلَ الذِّكْرِ إِن كُنتُمْ لَا تَعْلَمُونَ ﴾

Scholar
Search mode

If a man strikes a woman’s belly and she delivers a fetus that has unstable life, and another man strikes it and it dies, who is the killer?

Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner : Now, if a man strikes the belly of a pregnant woman and she delivers a fetus that has stable life, and another man strikes it and it dies, he says the killer is the first one, and upon him is the expiation.

The Shaykh : Even though this resembles the case of the one who causes and the one who directly acts. A man strikes the belly of a pregnant woman, and she delivers the fetus, and it has stable life. As for if she delivers it dead, the matter is clear. But if she delivers it with stable life and another man strikes it and kills it, he says the liability is on the first one, and the second one is punished. Why? Because by the act of delivery, the liability is established; the liability is established. And if not for the delivery, this man would not have been able to strike it or kill it. Therefore, the liability by the delivery precedes the liability by the killing. I do not think this issue is free from scholarly disagreement, because someone might say: if a man strikes the pregnant woman’s belly and the fetus falls, it might remain and not die, and the killer would be the second one. This issue, if Allah wills, our brother Abd al-Rahman will put it for us, so refer to al-Insaf regarding it. Yes.

The questioner : So as for if a man strikes a woman and she delivers a fetus in which there is unstable life, and another man strikes it, the liability is on the first one. And Ibn Abdullah returned. Ibn Qudamah (may Allah have mercy on him) said in his book, which preceded the East.

The Shaykh : No, people, now you see the matter is clear. Yesterday, my mind went to the idea that it says “and it has stable life.” Now it says “unstable life,” and this is clear with no issue at all, there is no issue. But yesterday, my mind went to the idea that it says “and it has stable life.” As for if he strikes her belly and she delivers a fetus in which there is unstable life, there is no doubt that the first one is the killer, clear? Because its movement now has become like the movement of a slaughtered animal, yes, it is in the ruling of a dead one, did you understand? And what made me say to review it was that my mind yesterday went to the idea that it says “and it has stable life,” so I said how can the second one kill it while it has stable life and the killer be the first one? This has an issue. But now, when I read it says “and it has unstable life,” the matter became clear, people? Now, if there is no need for a person to read it, there is benefit in it. Now, fine.
Source قناة «فضيلة الشيخ محمد بن صالح العثيمين»، 526 - لو ضرب بطن امرأة فألقت جنينا وفيه حياة غير مستقرة فضربه آخر فمات فمن القاتل؟
youtube.com
Flag this fatwa