If a person speaks between the two sermons, is his prayer considered invalid?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question : If a person speaks between the two sermons, is his prayer considered invalid? It is known that he forbade two people from speaking during the sermon.
Answer : No, the answer is no. Speaking between the two sermons is permissible, provided it does not disturb those around him. If it involves forbidding what is wrong, it is good. As for whether his prayer is considered invalid, what do you mean by "invalid"? Do you mean it is void, or that its reward is void? No. The hadith does not mean that the prayer is void and that he must repeat it. The meaning is that he is deprived of the reward for the congregation. If he speaks during the sermon, he is deprived of the reward for the congregation, which is what he would otherwise be rewarded for.
Answer : No, the answer is no. Speaking between the two sermons is permissible, provided it does not disturb those around him. If it involves forbidding what is wrong, it is good. As for whether his prayer is considered invalid, what do you mean by "invalid"? Do you mean it is void, or that its reward is void? No. The hadith does not mean that the prayer is void and that he must repeat it. The meaning is that he is deprived of the reward for the congregation. If he speaks during the sermon, he is deprived of the reward for the congregation, which is what he would otherwise be rewarded for.
Source
قناة «فضيلة الشيخ محمد بن صالح العثيمين»، 143 - 332 إذا تكلّم شخصٌ بين الخطبتين فهل تعتبر صلاته لاغية؟ الفتاوى الثلاثية - ابن عثيمين
youtube.com
youtube.com
