Text copied Link copied

Al-Fatawa – home

﴿ فَاسْأَلُوا أَهْلَ الذِّكْرِ إِن كُنتُمْ لَا تَعْلَمُونَ ﴾

Scholar
Search mode

One who has trade goods: Is the zakah paid from the goods themselves or from their value?

Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question : If a person has trade goods, from where does he pay? He pays from the value, but does he pay from the goods themselves or not? Some scholars hold that it is not permissible to pay from the goods of trade themselves. For example, a person who has cars, a person who has cars for trade, the owner of a large showroom who has cars for trade. When you ask, how many cars does he have? Ten. The most popular models, he has the most popular models. Is it permissible for him to pay these ten cars as the zakah of the one who has them, or is it obligatory for him to pay from their value?

Answer : Some scholars hold that it is obligatory to pay the zakah of trade goods from their value. They say: What is intended by trade goods?
The value. What is intended by them is the value. Does the owner of the showroom who has these cars want the cars? No. If a buyer comes for any car, he wants the value. So, if the value is what is intended by trade goods, it is obligatory to pay their zakah from the value. Also, are trade goods always of one type? The owner of trade goods, my brothers, if he sees profit in cars, he buys cars. If he sees profit in real estate, he buys land. If he sees profit in clothes, garments, and food, he buys that. So, the money he has is not his fixed capital, because he turns it into this and that. Therefore, it is obligatory to pay from the value, and this is the position of the majority of scholars, and this is the correct view. As for those who said it is permissible to pay from the goods themselves, they say: The default ruling for the zakah of wealth is that it is paid from the items themselves. This is the default. So, if this is the default, it is permissible to pay from trade goods if they are found in his possession, if they are found with him.
Now, if someone says: We should look at what is most beneficial for the poor. If it is more beneficial for the poor to receive the value, he pays the value. If it is more beneficial for the poor to receive the goods, he pays from the goods. If this distinction were made, it would be a view with merit. We should look at what is actually more beneficial. Perhaps you have forty cars, and among them is one car. If you give the poor person the value of this car, and the car is worth, for example, fifteen thousand, if you give him fifteen thousand, he cannot get a car of this type for less than eighteen thousand. But if you give him the car itself, that is more beneficial for him. So, we say that we choose the view that it is obligatory to pay from the value in the case of trade goods, and that if it is more beneficial for the poor to receive the goods themselves, they should receive the goods themselves, and if it is more beneficial for them to receive the value, he should pay the value.
Source قناة «فضيلة الشيخ محمد بن صالح العثيمين»، 467- من كان عنده عروض تجارة: هل يُخرج الزكاة من العروض أم من قيمتها؟ II ابن عثيمين
youtube.com
Flag this fatwa