What is the difference between cosmic permission and legislative permission?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question : He says: I have not grasped the difference between cosmic permission and legislative permission, so if you could repeat that with examples to clarify this issue?
Answer : Cosmic permission means the cosmic command of Allah the Exalted, and legislative permission is His legislative command. For example, all legislations fall under the category of legislative permission, and all created beings fall under the category of cosmic permission. They are close to will, both cosmic and legislative. Do you understand now? Yes? Good. If a person stands up to pray, both cosmic and legislative permission converge in his case. It is cosmic because he prayed by the will of Allah, and it is legislative because Allah prescribed the prayer. And if a person prostrates to an idol, that involves cosmic permission but not legislative permission.
Answer : Cosmic permission means the cosmic command of Allah the Exalted, and legislative permission is His legislative command. For example, all legislations fall under the category of legislative permission, and all created beings fall under the category of cosmic permission. They are close to will, both cosmic and legislative. Do you understand now? Yes? Good. If a person stands up to pray, both cosmic and legislative permission converge in his case. It is cosmic because he prayed by the will of Allah, and it is legislative because Allah prescribed the prayer. And if a person prostrates to an idol, that involves cosmic permission but not legislative permission.
Source
قناة «فضيلة الشيخ محمد بن صالح العثيمين»، 281 - 332 ما الفرق بين الإذن الكوني والشرعي؟ - الفتاوى الثلاثية - ابن عثيمين
youtube.com
youtube.com
