Is the intention to imitate the disbelievers a condition?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
Question : Is the intention to imitate a condition, or is it not?
Answer : Someone might say that the intention to imitate is a condition, because he said, "Whoever imitates," and "imitates" implies an action and an intention. However, whoever looks at the 'illah (operative cause) knows that the ruling is established whenever the imitation occurs, or more accurately, whenever the resemblance occurs. For this reason, the Shaykh al-Islam (may Allah have mercy on him) stated that the ruling applies whenever the resemblance occurs, even without intention. This is because the 'illah does not change based on the presence or absence of intention. The 'illah is that whoever sees this man says, "This is a disbeliever." Intention is not a condition for this. However, if a person is in a country where there are no disbelievers who wear this clothing, and he does not know about the clothing of the disbelievers in their lands, and he wears clothing that resembles the clothing of the disbelievers in their lands, but in this country the disbelievers do not wear it, and he has not washed it, then we might say here that there is no imitation, because the 'illah has been completely removed.
Answer : Someone might say that the intention to imitate is a condition, because he said, "Whoever imitates," and "imitates" implies an action and an intention. However, whoever looks at the 'illah (operative cause) knows that the ruling is established whenever the imitation occurs, or more accurately, whenever the resemblance occurs. For this reason, the Shaykh al-Islam (may Allah have mercy on him) stated that the ruling applies whenever the resemblance occurs, even without intention. This is because the 'illah does not change based on the presence or absence of intention. The 'illah is that whoever sees this man says, "This is a disbeliever." Intention is not a condition for this. However, if a person is in a country where there are no disbelievers who wear this clothing, and he does not know about the clothing of the disbelievers in their lands, and he wears clothing that resembles the clothing of the disbelievers in their lands, but in this country the disbelievers do not wear it, and he has not washed it, then we might say here that there is no imitation, because the 'illah has been completely removed.
Source
قناة «فضيلة الشيخ محمد بن صالح العثيمين»، 4421هل يشترط قصد التشبه بالكفار؟📔 الشرح الممتع على زاد المستقنع - ابن عثيمين
youtube.com
youtube.com
