What is the ruling on keeping magazines and newspapers that contain images?
Machine translationRead the Arabic original
The questioner : He asks: What is the ruling on keeping magazines and newspapers that contain some images, where it is difficult to remove or obliterate them?
The Shaykh : First, we must know that newspapers and magazines that are produced for the sake of these images are not permissible; it is not permissible to acquire, sell, or buy them, because they contain images, and they may include images that are provocative for young men and women. As for scientific and literary magazines that do not carry bad ideas or false beliefs, but contain some images, there is nothing wrong with them. However, is it obligatory to obliterate the image? It appears to me that it is not obligatory, due to the hardship and difficulty involved, and if one scratches it, it ruins the book. It is well known that the image in the middle of the book is covered and not visible. Now, what do you say about what is called the "burdah"? Do you know it? Please, whoever knows the "burdah," tell us.
The questioner : Yes, this is the original form, but when things become, by custom, fashion magazines...
The Shaykh : Yes, it is called a "burdah," and there is no dispute over the terminology; they call it a "burdah." I see that this "burdah" should not be distributed among people. Because what is in their hands are women, and most women do not have that far-reaching thinking. So if she sees this new attire that is not the previous attire, what does she do? She looks for it. If she is an employee, the matter is easy; she takes it from the box and gives it. If she is not an employee, she calls out to her father or mother, "I want something like this." And if she is a wife, problems arise with her husband: "Buy this and that." Therefore, I see that these fashion magazines should not be placed in homes at all, considering that most of the fashions are contrary to the Shari'ah dress. And we ask Allah for protection for us and for you.
The Shaykh : First, we must know that newspapers and magazines that are produced for the sake of these images are not permissible; it is not permissible to acquire, sell, or buy them, because they contain images, and they may include images that are provocative for young men and women. As for scientific and literary magazines that do not carry bad ideas or false beliefs, but contain some images, there is nothing wrong with them. However, is it obligatory to obliterate the image? It appears to me that it is not obligatory, due to the hardship and difficulty involved, and if one scratches it, it ruins the book. It is well known that the image in the middle of the book is covered and not visible. Now, what do you say about what is called the "burdah"? Do you know it? Please, whoever knows the "burdah," tell us.
The questioner : Yes, this is the original form, but when things become, by custom, fashion magazines...
The Shaykh : Yes, it is called a "burdah," and there is no dispute over the terminology; they call it a "burdah." I see that this "burdah" should not be distributed among people. Because what is in their hands are women, and most women do not have that far-reaching thinking. So if she sees this new attire that is not the previous attire, what does she do? She looks for it. If she is an employee, the matter is easy; she takes it from the box and gives it. If she is not an employee, she calls out to her father or mother, "I want something like this." And if she is a wife, problems arise with her husband: "Buy this and that." Therefore, I see that these fashion magazines should not be placed in homes at all, considering that most of the fashions are contrary to the Shari'ah dress. And we ask Allah for protection for us and for you.
Source
قناة «خزائن الرحمن»، دروس وفتاوى المسجد الحرام {1418}{13} سماحة الشيخ العلامة محمد بن صالح العثيمين
youtube.com (57:19)
youtube.com (57:19)
